Comment on this article
In print
November 1999
by Bruce Fellman
Thomas
Hine '69
The Rise
and Fall of the American Teenager
Bard/Avon, $24.00
In The Catcher
in the Rye, Holden Caulfield, J.D. Salinger's archetypal teen, tries
to end adult concern about his behavior by saying, "Don't worry about
me . I'm just going through a phase right now."
The same could
be said, argues social critic Thomas Hine, about the way modern society
views adolescents -- and it's a phase we'd do well to outgrow. "The teenager
is a social invention, one that took shape during the first half of the
20th century in response to a society very different from our own," says
Hine. "We live in a different world now, and we must reconsider how we
think about the lives of the young."
The author
begins this examination of the rise of the concept that the years 13 through
19 constitute a special "phase" of life with a true horror story: the
New Jersey high school senior who gave birth in a lavatory stall at her
prom, deposited her baby in a trash can, tidied up, and then proceeded
to dance the night away. An explanation of her behavior was "close at
hand," says Hine, summing up popular opinion. "She was a contemporary
teenager, a member of a generation that's out of control."
Such a viewpoint
is of surprisingly recent vintage. In 1904, psychologist Granville Stanley
Hall defined adolescence as a scary time, with school being "virtually
the only safe place for the menacing young."
And yet, for
most of human history, the onset of puberty served more as a time that
marked the beginning of adulthood than an event that "required" segregating
the afflicted into a distinct subclass. Indeed, until the beginning of
the 20th century, adolescents, who are, after all, at the peak of their
physical capabilities, simply worked hard, found mates, and started caring
for families. If teens had identity crises, a term invented by psychologist
Erik Erikson, they kept them to themselves.
But with increasing
industrialization came the increased emphasis on mental agility and a
concomitant decrease in jobs that required more brawn than brains, says
Hine. Such a workforce needed new levels of education, and the result
was high school, without which, says the author, "there are no teenagers."
By bringing
teenagers together in one place, high school -- the first public one opened
in Boston in 1821, but near universal enrollment didn't occur until after
the Second World War -- provided "a fertile ground for the development
of youth culture." But times are vastly dif- ferent now, says Hine, and
the dominant notion that the proper place for teens is in what amounts
to custodial institutions needs to change as well.
"Teenagers
are people of whom too much is asked and too little is expected," says
Hine, arguing for a new social and educational system that enables teens
to "figure out how things really work" and to better "imagine and begin
to construct their lives . . . Once we understand that the teenager -- this
weird, alienated, frightening yet enviable creature -- is a figment of
our imagination, the monstrous progeny of marketing and high school, all
generations will benefit."

Bryan Di Salvatore
'70
A Clever Base-Ballist: The Life and Times of John
Montgomery Ward
Pantheon, $27.50
The World Series
is over, but sometime before opening day next April, baseball fans are
almost certain to hear a team owner opine: "The results of the past season
prove that salaries must come down. We believe that players in insisting
upon exorbitant prices are injuring their own interests."
This familiar
refrain, however, dates from the end of the 1879 baseball season, and
while some aspects of the game have changed -- there was no pitcher's
mound, and the umpire could ask players and fans for help on judging close
plays -- then, as now, there was plenty of labor unrest. Leading the athletes
was John Montgomery Ward, the Hall of Fame pitcher, and later shortstop
and manager, whose plaque at Cooperstown notes blandly that he "played
[an] important part in establishing modern organized baseball."
Ward's role
in crafting the National Pastime is the subject of this biography, which
examines the career of "one of the most forceful brains the game has ever
known." In prose whose cadences often evoke the flavor of the late 19th
century, Bryan Di Salvatore offers a portrait of Ward, a superstar who
once won 39 games in a single season, pitched a perfect game, and garnered
2,151 hits in his 17 years as a "base-ballist." But it was his work behind
the scenes that set the stage for modern professional baseball.
The author
offers an in-depth look at how Ward, who earned his law degree at Columbia
during the off-season, led players to organize the "Brotherhood," a union
that challenged the restrictive contracts of team owners. In 1890, the
renegade players even organized a league of their own.
Ward and the
Brotherhood were soon defeated by the entrenched forces of the National
League. The issue, however, never died, and in 1972, the U.S. Supreme
Court granted Ward a posthumous victory.

Chang-Rae
Lee '87
A Gesture Life
Riverhead Books, $23.95
"In the end,
I have learned I must make whatever peace and solace of my own," says
Franklin Hata, the Korean-American protagonist of a novel that examines
the compromises and costs an outsider must make to fit into a society.
In this carefully crafted examination of a life, "Doc" Hata, who ran a
medical supply business and was a pillar of the fictional town of Bedley
Run, takes readers from his well-maintained and proper home through a
series of formative events. All of them proved ultimately painful because
no matter how hard Hata would try, he couldn't quite mesh with his surroundings.
There is a
harrowing tale of World War II, in which Hata, who was serving as a medic
with the Japanese army, befriends, falls in love with, but cannot save
a young woman brought into camp as a prostitute. His attempt in this country
to right that wrong by adopting an orphan fails as she grows up and leaves
him. A love affair doesn't work out, and the business he spent a lifetime
developing fails in the hands of the couple to whom he sold it.
But Hata may
find a measure of peace, for his daughter returns with a child -- and
a new role for him. As this melancholy story ends, the outsider is coming
in.

Christopher Tilghman '68
The Way People Run
Random House, $21.95
Mason's Retreat,
Christopher Tilghman's first novel ("In Print," Yale
Alumni Magazine, Sum. '96), was
rich with the coastal rhythms, watermen, and salty tang of the Chesapeake
Bay region of Maryland. In his new collection of short stories, the author
revisits this landscape, as well as new terrain in the American West.
But regardless of setting, Tilghman's characters continue to wrestle with
a familiar theme: the relationships between decent but somehow flawed
people that never seem to quite work out.
In "Things Left Undone,"
for example, a Maryland-shore dairy farmer named Denny is trying to cope
with his son's death and his wife's betrayal. As he and his father attend
to farm chores, the men talk:
"I'm not anyone to pry,"
the father said, "but things have to be managed, don't they?"
"You don't manage a marriage like fences and Johnson grass, Dad. There's
nothing I can do."
"There is always something," said his father, his eyes filling.
In each of these poignant
examinations of the human heart, the characters attempt, always without
complete success, to figure out the right thing to do. So when Denny and
his wife try to find a way back together, it will not be a "happier ever
after" life. The characters in Tilghman's universe have a much more tenuous
hold on the future. But "it will be enough, not perhaps for every man
and every woman, but [enough] for her, and for him, for now."

Brief
Reviews
James
M. Banner Jr. '57 and Harold C. Cannon
The Elements of Learning Yale University Press, $18.50
In a celebration of the learning process, two veteran teachers offer
a wealth of suggestions "about how you can become a good student,
think of yourself as one, and enjoy yourself in the process."
Roger
G. Kennedy '49
Burr, Hamilton, and Jefferson: A Study in Character
Oxford University Press, $30.00
"Aaron
Burr is the central figure in this book because his character was
better than his reputation," says the historian-writer, who attempts
to restore Burr to his rightful place in the founding of the Republic.
Paul
LaFarge '92
The Artist of the Missing
Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, $13.00
In
this evocative debut novel, the protagonist searches for a lost
love in a shape-shifting and dreamscape city that is equal parts
Franz Kafka, Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Lewis Carroll, and George Orwell.
Susan
M. Lark and James A. Richards '64
The Chemistry of Success: Six Secrets of Peak Performance
Bay Books, $24.95
Some people seem to naturally possess extra energy, stamina, productivity,
and creativity. The authors offer a biochemical explanation and
a program aimed at maximizing potential.
Ruth
Lord '50MA
Henry F. duPont and Winterthur: A Daughter's Portrait
Yale University Press, $27.50
Before
the 175-room mansion known as Winterthur became a well known museum
of Americana, it was home to Ruth Lord, who recounts her upbringing
and the legendary lifestyle of the duPont family.
Beryl
Satter '92PhD
Each Mind a Kingdom: American Women, Sexual Purity, and the New
Thought Movement, 1875-1920
University of California Press, $39.95
The turn-of-the-century
New Thought movement helped bridge the gap between the image of
self-sacrificing Victorian womanhood and the "modern girl" of
the 1920s.

Books
Received
Richard C. Beacham
'68, '73MFA, '73DFA
Spectacle Entertainments of Early Imperial Rome
Yale University Press, $35.00
John W. Blassingame
'70PhD and John R. McKivigan, editors
The Frederick Douglass Papers: Autobiographical Writings, Volume
One-Narrative
Yale University Press, $45.00
Martin Nelson Burton
'85JD
The Whale Comedian
London Town Press, $15.95
Stephen L. Carter
'79JD, William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Law
The Dissent of the Governed: A Meditation on Law, Religion, and
Loyalty
Harvard University Press, $12.95
Donald Caton '58
What a Blessing She Had Chloroform: The Medical and Social Response
to the Pain of Childbirth
Yale University Press, $30.00
Randi Danforth '76,
editor
Culinaria: The United States, A Culinary Discovery
Konemann Verlags, $39.98
Margaret A. Farley,
Gilbert L. Stark Professor of Christian Ethics, and Serene Jones,
Associate Professor of Theology, editors
Liberating Eschatology: Essays in Honor of Letty M. Russell
Westminster/John Knox Press, $24.95
James Farlow '80PhD
and Michael K. Brett-Surman, editors
The Complete Dinosaur
Indiana University Press, $35.00
Jo-David Fine '72,
MD, MPH, Eugene Bauer MD, Joseph McGuire '55MD, and Alan Moshell
MD
Epidermolysis Bullosa: Clinical, Epidemiologic, and Laboratory
Advances, and the Findings of the National Epidermolysis Bullosa
Registry
Johns Hopkins University Press, $89.95
Paul Corby Finney
'62, editor
Seeing Beyond the Word: The Visual Arts and the Calvinist Tradition
William B. Eerdmans, $65.00
Noel E. Firth '58
and James H. Noren
Soviet Defense Spending: A History of CIA Estimates, 1950-1990
Texas A&M Press, $49.95
Jonathan Freedman
'84PhD and Richard Millington, editors
Hitchcock's America
Oxford University Press, $45.00
Sage Goodwin '27,
'30BFA
Future's Friends
Pentland Press, $22.95
Michael Graetz and
Jerry Mashaw, Sterling Professor
of Law
True Security: Rethinking American Social Insurance
Yale University Press, $40.00
Alan M. Grosman '57MA
New Jersey Family Law
Lexis Law Publishing, $99.00
Courtney W. Howland
'79JD, editor
Religious Fundamentalisms and the Human Rights of Women
St. Martin's Press, $45.00
James Z. Lee '74
and Wang Feng
One Quarter of Humanity: Malthusian Mythology and Chinese Realities
Harvard University Press, $47.50
Eli H. Newberger
'62, '66MD
The Men They Will Become: The Nature and Nurture of Male Character
Perseus Books, $25.00
Luc R. Pelletier
'82MSN, Carole A. Shea, Elizabeth C. Poster, Gail W. Stuart, and
Marilyn P Verhey, editors
Advanced Practice Nursing in Psychiatric and Mental Health Care
Mosby, $59.95
Rachel Resnick '85
Go West Young F*cked-Up Chick
St. Martin's Press, $22.95
Susan Rose-Ackerman,
Henry R. Luce Professor of Law and Political Science
Corruption and Government: Causes, Consequences, and Reform
Cambridge University Press, $49.95
Stephanie Sandler
'81PhD, Editor
Rereading Russian Poetry
Yale University Press, $40.00
Jerry Selness '63
Primitive Benchmark: A Short Treatise on a General Theory of
Sailing with the Limits for Sailboat Speed
Windward Enterprises, $19.99
Maxim D. Shrayer
'95 PhD
The World of Nabokov's Stories
University of Texas Press, $49.95
Mark W. Travis '70Dra
The Director's Journey: The Creative Collaboration between Directors,
Writers, and Actors
Michael Wiese Productions, $26.95
Sergio Troncoso '92MPhil
The Last Tortilla and Other Stories
University of Arizona Press, $40.00
Traci West '81
Wounds of the Spirit: Black Women, Violence and Resistance Ethics
New York University Press, $55.00
Max Wilk '41, '41Dra
The Golden Age of Television: Notes from the Survivors
Silver Spring Press, $14.95
|