| |
Comment on this article
The
Arts and the City
Major
exhibitions at Yale galleries this fall serve as a potent reminder
of the University's unique commitment to the arts. Elsewhere, such
commitment has been harnessed as an engine of urban renewal. Will
the Elm City be next?
October
1996
by Bruce Fellman
In the
world of the arts, the intersection of York and Chapel streets on
the edge of the Yale campus is a very high-rent neighborhood.
On the northwest corner is Paul Rudolph's 1963 Art
and Architecture building, a landmark in architectural history
that houses two of Yale's leading professional schools. Directly
across the street is the University Art Gallery, the first major
building designed by the renowned Louis Kahn and arguably one of
the best teaching museums in the country. To the right is the Yale
Repertory Theatre, which regularly draws raves in the New York Times for its innovative Drama School productions of work ranging
from Shakespeare to John Guare. And just down Chapel toward the
Green is the British Art Center, Louis Kahn's last work and home
to the largest collection of British art outside the United Kingdom.
The power of these institutions
is being highlighted this fall with an extraordinary concentration
of exhibitions. The BAC's contribution is "British Art Treasures
from Russian Imperial Collections in the Hermitage," a show
that includes works as diverse as portraits by Van Dyck, china by
Wedgwood, watches, jewelry, and a bathtub-sized, sterling-silver
winecooler. Meanwhile, the Art Gallery is mounting "I, Claudia,"
an exhibition of 170 works illustrating the public and private lives
of women in ancient Rome. On a smaller scale, but hardly less impressive,
is "Thomas Eakins: the Rowing Pictures," an exhibit at
the Gallery of studies and finished paintings by one of America's
most admired turn-of-the-century masters.
Such exhibitions may
be a testament to the power of the arts at Yale, but now the unique
assemblage of institutions that have sponsored them is being looked
at in a new light. From New York's SoHo to Chicago's River North
area and SoMa (south of Market Street) in San Francisco, the arts
have long proven to be one of the most effective catalysts for urban
uplift, reinvigorating whole neighborhoods that had fallen into
decline. And officials from both Yale and New Haven are beginning
to focus on the potential of the local arts institutions to do the
same for their own distressed downtown. "Every community is
looking for a way to become a destination, and the arts have always
been a major draw," says Matthew Nemerson '81MPPM, president
of the Greater New Haven Chamber of Commerce. "Yale's longstanding
tradition of investing in museums, galleries, and theater performances
brings vitality to streets that might otherwise be dark." Bitsy
Clark, the president of the New Haven Arts Council, is even more
optimistic. The arts, she recently told a reporter for the Yale
Daily News, "will be the savior for New Haven."
This
is hardly the first time the Elm City has heard predictions of a
renaissance. In
the 1960s, a massive infusion of money from Washington was supposed
to transform Yale's hometown into a "model city." And
intermittently since then Yale Presidents and local politicians alike have heralded the potential of initiatives
like Science Park and the Ninth Square. (See "The Emerging
Urban University," April
1995.)
In city after city,
however, the arts have proved singularly successful as a source
of both civic pride and increased revenue. And New Haven has more
than its share of arts organizations. The problem is that until
now they have never been exploited in any coordinated way for the
common good.
Yale's first step in
this direction is a campaign to renovate its own arts facilities.
Two years ago, the University convened an "arts area planning
committee," a group composed of professional-school deans,
department heads, museum directors, librarians, planners and administrators,
and an outside architectural consultant (James Stewart Polshek and
Partners), to conduct a thorough review of the buildings serving
the schools of art, architecture, and drama, as well as the galleries.
(The Music School, which occupies a mini-arts district of its own
on the other side of the campus, was not a major part of this review.)
The committee, chaired by Jules Prown, the Paul Mellon Professor
of the History of Art, finished its work last winter. "Refurbishing
the physical fabric of the University is, of course, a top priority,"
says Prown. "There's no way we can dodge the deferred-maintenance
bullet."
According to President
Levin, planners are now reviewing options that over a period of
years may involve a "nine-figure investment" in the reorganization
and upgrading of many of the University's artistic endeavors. "We
have a rich treasure here, but it's housed in facilities that are
either inadequate for the demands of the next century or are in
serious disrepair," says Diana Kleiner, Yale's deputy provost
for the arts. The Art Gallery, for example, has leaky windows and
needs a new roof. Masonry has been known to fall from the ceiling
of the University Theater. The Art and Architecture building is only now getting adequate heating and
cooling systems.
The space crunch is
becoming critical. "We're an art museum housed in a work of
art," notes Susan Vogel, the Henry J. Heinz II Director of
the gallery, "but we haven't grown since we opened in 1953.
Our collections, on the other hand, have grown exponentially, and
we need to be able to make our holdings more accessible to scholars,
students, and the general public." While the details of how
to accomplish this remain to be worked out, preliminary discussions
have touched on the construction of a building that would provide
both increased storage for works of art and better facilities for
their display and study. Well aware of the sensitivity of the city
to any such undertaking, planners have also discussed adding such
now-familiar amenities as gift shops or a restaurant.
Space
has also been an issue for art and architecture, which have cohabited
since the Rudolf building opened in 1963, not always with the greatest
of ease. (The
sculptors long ago outgrew their quarters on York Street and are
now housed in Hammond Hall, which is near Ingalls Rink.) "Separating
'A' and 'A' better serves both disciplines," notes David Pease,
who recently stepped down as dean of the School of Art. "We
need a lot of flexible space that enables us to respond to changes,
and we'd like to consolidate our programs, if not under one roof
then at least in the same neighborhood." Accordingly, officials
have been looking at nearby properties that might be converted to
a freestanding art headquarters.
A similar situation
prevails at the School of Drama, whose operations are scattered
among four campus buildings. Campus planners hope to bring all these
fragments together in a more cohesive "community of artists
and scholars," not just for the University's organizational
purposes, but for the positive effect such a concentration could
have on New Haven. There are hurdles, though, and they are more
than structural. "We're natural allies, but we're also painters,
actors, curators, and so forth -- and as such, we have a loyalty to
our own home base," says Pease. "How do we get all these
tribes to become a nation?"
One way to build community,
Pease and his colleagues have suggested, is to mix compatible disciplines:
If the Art School gets a new home,
planners have suggested that it could profitably share its headquarters
with, say, experimental theater. "Increasingly, the future
belongs to people who have learned to collaborate," says Pease.
"The lone-wolf idea, which has always been the basis of being
an artist, is a frontier kind of attitude that seems to be shifting,
and a major cause of the shift is the computer."
Spurred by its dean,
Fred Koetter, the Architecture School is already heavily involved
with computer-aided design, and the ubiquity of computer networks
has made possible a kind of "virtual community" in which
an unprecedented degree of collaboration and communication is routine.
To enhance this, Koetter, Pease, Richard Benson -- a professor of photography
who is succeeding Pease as dean of the Art School -- and other committee
members have proposed creating a "visual imaging center"
as a key part of a throughly overhauled and updated library system
for the arts.
"We
deal with images all the time,"
says Prown, adding that the ease with which the computer can store,
retrieve, and manipulate artwork that has been translated into digital
form is already changing the face of scholarship in the arts. And
though it was once denounced as the "anti-Christ," the
computer is now accepted as an artistic tool that has opened new
creative opportunities. The fact that the proposed imaging center
will be a core facility used by many different kinds of artists
should, say planners, promote the kinds of interactions that are
considered critical. "The membranes that have separated the
arts are becoming more permeable," says Prown. "Everything
is coming together."
If the computer is the
means by which artists mingle, then artistic productions, particularly
gallery exhibitions and theater performances, are a prime method
of bringing the University and the outside community into contact
with each other. There is no better illustration of this than the
"Treasures from the Hermitage" exhibit that opens this
month. "Even if you went to St. Petersburg, you couldn't see
what you'll see in New Haven," says Patrick McCaughey, who
last April became director of the Center
for British Art. "The Hermitage show will be a once-in-a-lifetime
experience."
McCaughey, a 53-year-old
Australian who favors oversized bow ties, taught art history both
in his native country and at Harvard, and served as director at
Hartford's Wadsworth Atheneum before coming to New Haven. In all
of those roles, he showed a taste for the controversial, and an
affinity for publicity. In 1990, while still at the Atheneum, McCaughey
brought the late photographer Robert
Mapplethorpe's highly controversial "The Perfect Moment"
show to Hartford. The exhibit had already provoked the wrath of
several U.S. legislators, and it eventually resulted in an obscenity
indictment against Dennis Barrie, then director of Cincinnati's
Contemporary Arts Center, when he attempted to display the photographs.
(A jury later found Barrie innocent.)
Museums, says McCaughey,
have an obligation to show art that is "difficult and arresting,"
and while he says it would be "cheap and nasty" to seek
out notoriety for its own sake, it would be equally irresponsible
to avoid it. "We shouldn't be timid," he says.
To be sure, the "Treasures"
exhibit will not prompt visits by the police or antipornography
protesters, but bringing the mammoth show to Yale was certainly
not an undertaking for the faint-of-heart. The exhibit is the result
of a conversation its chief curator Brian Allen, the director of
studies at London's Paul Mellon Centre for Studies in British Art,
had in early 1994 with Larissa Dukelskaya, keeper of prints at the
Hermitage and at the time a visiting fellow at the BAC's counterpart
in England. "We knew that among the millions of objects in
that museum was a significant collection of British paintings, many
of them collected by Catherine the Great," says Allen, who
asked Dukelskaya to float the idea to her boss in St. Petersburg
of loaning Yale a modest selection of this artwork for a show in
New Haven.
Hermitage director Mikhail
Piotrovsky proved agreeable, and when Allen and Duncan Robinson,
who was then the BAC's director, traveled to Russia to make selections,
they discovered that the Empress had been a consummate Anglophile
whose desire to surround herself with things British was part of
a major shift in Russian society. "The rulers were beginning
to look westward," says Allen.
With the enthusiastic
cooperation of Hermitage officials, and with a major grant from
the Ford Motor Company and additional support from the National
Endowment for the Arts and the Federal Council on the Arts and Humanities,
Allen and his colleagues put together a much more ambitious show
than originally planned. The New Haven audience (and later, audiences
in Toledo and Saint Louis) can view "a group of rarely seen
and thoroughly splendid objects from a time when Russia was shifting
from being an insular feudal society into a great world power,"
Allen says.
The "Treasures"
show will also help advance the state of the art scholar's art.
"Blockbuster shows have become the vehicles for the promotion
of new scholarship," notes BAC director McCaughey. "The
best recent monographs in English have been the catalogs of major
exhibitions, and equally important, such shows provide an opportunity
for new knowledge to be widely disseminated to an audience that
wants the highest level of artistic and intellectual stimulation."
The "Treasures"
catalog, which includes 12 essays produced by scholars from
Russia, Europe, and the United States, should provide the precise
blend of the "critical and the creative" that McCaughey
wants the BAC to represent.
The "I, Claudia"
show that opened at the Yale Art Gallery in early September (and
will travel to San Antonio, Texas, next January and to Raleigh,
North Carolina, in April 1997) is no less ambitious. The story of
Roman women has never been told entirely through works of art, notes
Deputy Provost Diana Kleiner, who is also Dunham Professor of Classics
and the History of Art and is co-curating the exhibition with Susan
B. Matheson, the Gallery's curator of ancient art. "We've assembled
an extraordinary collection of objects, many of which have never
traveled before, from museums throughout the U.S. and Canada,"
says Kleiner. Among the objects are statues, busts, funeral vases,
portraits, pieces of furniture, papyrus divorce and marriage certificates,
as well as coins, jewelry, perfume bottles, and toys, including
one of the oldest rag dolls in existence. To create a sense of the
ancient context, the organizers have built architectural mock-ups -- complete
with authentic graffiti -- of the settings in which the objects would
have been used.
Through artifacts and
architecture, the show demonstrates how Roman women of all ages
and social classes lived. "Women certainly weren't liberated
and they couldn't vote, but they were often political movers and
shakers, and they played a significant role in society and the arts,"
says Matheson. "They had many values and virtues, particularly
family values, we can relate to now. Through art, we can bring real
women to life."
An exploration of social
history is also an important part of the "The Rowing Pictures,"
the Eakins exhibit that opens at the Gallery this month following
its June debut in Washington, D.C. (From New Haven, it will travel
to Cleveland.) "Rowers are not like other people," notes
Helen Cooper, curator of American paintings and sculpture, who put
the show together. "There's a unique sense of discipline and
hard work behind the sport, and the people involved never forget
the experience. Viewers will discover that Eakins, a rower himself,
was every bit as intense and disciplined as his subjects."
In comparison
to its counterparts, this is a relatively small show.
There are 23 works of art -- oil paintings, watercolors, and drawings -- that
were done between 1871 and 1874, when a rowing race was front-page
news and drew crowds of thousands. It was also the beginning of
Eakins's professional career as an artist, and by assembling all
the known pictures he did on rowing -- the first time this has been
done, says Cooper -- "We're providing a window on one period of
someone's life."
Apart from the scholarship
behind them, what distinguishes all three of these exhibitions is
a heightened interest in making that scholarship available in a
form that engages as well as informs. And in this, the shows seem
an appropriate vehicle for the underlying message of University
planners about exploiting Yale's artistic riches to help improve
its host city.
Those efforts are being
accompanied by some significant collaborations between Yale and
New Haven. Last spring, Yale joined the city in backing efforts
to put the >Shubert
Performing Arts Center, which has been one of the premier tryout
stages for Broadway-bound plays, on firm financial footing. In June,
Yale helped sponsor and host New Haven's first annual International
Festival of Arts and Ideas. The five-day festival, the brainchild
of Anne Calabresi, a longtime champion of the arts in the city (and
wife of former Law School dean Guido Calabresi), included such performers
as Ladysmith Black Mambazo, Ellis and Branford Marsalis, Cirque
Baroque, and Buffy Sainte Marie, and attracted an estimated 50,000
people. And in August, Mayor DeStefano announced that the long-stalled
plans for a luxury hotel on the Green were going forward with a
commitment by the Omni Hotel corporation to renovate the shuttered
Park Plaza. According to DeStefano, the result
will be "the finest four-star hotel between New York and Boston."
One of the attractions of the project, DeStefano emphasized, was
that it "links us to a strength: arts and entertainment."
Boosterism aside, by
concentrating on an area in which they have unquestioned strength,
Yale and New Haven may craft something greater than the sum of their
parts.  |
|