Comment on this article
Remembering John Morton Blum
January/February 2012
by The Editors
John Morton Blum, Sterling Professor of History
Emeritus, died on October 17, just as our last issue was going to press. We
reported on his death, but until now couldn’t report (in print) on what
followed: an outflowing of obituaries and tributes that drew a portrait of a
well-loved teacher and admired scholar.
In The Republican Roosevelt,
Professor Blum argued that Theodore Roosevelt had reinvigorated a presidency
that had been in decline since the Civil War. … Though that view is accepted
now, Roosevelt’s presidency, from 1901 to 1909, was considered mediocre at the
time, partly because he had not led the country in war. He was portrayed by
many as a buffoonish caricature of a national leader. … Professor Blum argued
that, in fact, Roosevelt’s genius for governance established a model for Wilson
and Franklin Roosevelt as well as all the others who followed him.
—Paul Vitello, New York Times

I would argue the hallmark of his career was his
three-volume summation of [Henry] Morgenthau’s tenure as Treasury Secretary, From
the Morgenthau Diaries. … Blum combed through and helped to organize
the Morgenthau Diaries and transformed them into a three-volume history, often
interviewing Morgenthau himself to gain perspective. This decade-long work is
absolutely essential to anyone delving into the Morgenthau story.
—author Peter Moreira, on his Morgenthau-themed blog The
Jew Who Defeated Hitler

Wearing tweed jackets and bow ties, uttering
beautifully formed sentences seemingly without forethought, Blum struck his
disciples in the 1980s as a classic Ivy League type. … Some years later, after
becoming a historian myself, I read A Life with History (2004),
Blum’s autobiography. It was a revelation. For one thing, I learned that Blum
was Jewish—a fact that, given his name, should have been perfectly obvious yet
was somehow obscured by his tweedy aura. … A Life with History also
revealed how much Blum’s schooling—first at Andover, then at
Harvard—transformed him, imbuing him with the Ivy style that by the 1980s
seemed intrinsic to his identity.
—historian David Greenberg ’90 at Slate.com

One week Professor Blum asked for two students to help
rake leaves. I jumped at the chance to experience more of what Yale was all
about. I raked leaves with another student for a few hours. Professor Blum
talked with us a bit and served us lunch. But the most amazing thing was that
he had a visitor just stop by for lunch, an older gentleman who introduced
himself as Kingman Brewster!
—Ian Rosi ’88, in an e-mail to the Yale
Alumni Magazine

He often appeared on television documentaries, but his
most unusual screen performance came in 1983 when he had a cameo in the Woody Allen
film Zelig,
discussing the fictional title character’s ubiquitous presence at major events
of the 20th century. “He wasn’t much of a moviegoer,” his son said Saturday.
“It took him a while to realize Woody Allen was on the phone. He thought it was
one of his students playing a prank.”
—Matt Schudel, Washington Post

Thirty years after I sat through a semester of lectures
on the Progressive Era, and one of the longest final exams that I ever wrote, I
still have detailed and lasting memories of John Blum: his Theodore Roosevelt
imitation, his holding forth at lunch with students, a healthy dose of pomp during
one-to-one chats in his office, and above all the wisdom imparted during a
brief vivid encounter with the man, his bow tie, and his pipe as I exited SSS
114 after writing that exam and headed into a snowy, dreary New Haven. I
thanked the man for the course, and I shared the wish that I could remain an
undergraduate for more than the standard four years, so that I could take all
of the provocative courses in what was then the Blue Book—the Yale course
catalog. No, you don’t want to stay, Blum replied; four years is plenty of time
to devote to college. After that, you should go exploring.
—Michael Madison ’83, Professor of Law at the
University of Pittsburgh, on his blog Madisonian  |