| |
Comment on this article
Summer Fiction
July/August 2009
Spoiled
by Caitlin Macy '92
Random House, $24
Reviewed by Julia Glass '78
Novelist Julia Glass '78 is the author of I See You
Everywhere and the
National Book Award-winning Three Junes.
Caitlin Macy '92 possesses the eye
of an anthropologist: keenly perceptive, cool verging on glacial. In these nine
tales, she casts her astute gaze into the lives of educated, cosmopolitan
American women who’ve swapped their souls for status or security: for a wealthy
husband, a career in film or finance, the dream apartment (that perfectly situated
classic six)—even a coveted nanny. "Spoiled" they may well be, but they are
often reflective and insecure as well, vulnerable to the complex emotions of
intelligent people who see every nuance of the compromises defining their
lives.
| |
Macy gets the details deliciously (and comically) right. |
In "The Secret Vote," a successful
lawyer, pregnant for the first time in her late thirties, begins to reappraise
the integrity of everyone around her, including her husband, as she awaits her
amnio results. In "The Red Coat," a woman with too much time on her hands
vacillates between contempt and envy for her Ukrainian housekeeper, finally
committing an act of theft in order to win the younger, more attractive woman's
allegiance. "Taroudant" features a honeymooning wife who, fed up with her
husband’s insouciance, strikes out on her own in a remote Moroccan village—a
peevish move that leads to an act of violence, though not the one you're
expecting. You'd be hard-pressed to think of these protagonists as "heroines."
But if you love gloating over the foibles and miseries of the haute
bourgeoisie, you’ll savor this suite of well-honed portraits like a box of
fashionably dark chocolate bonbons.
Macy is a skillful writer and gets
the details deliciously (and comically) right. The ideal nanny is possessed of
an "upbeat tranquility." A gathering of women trade complaints about their
housekeepers' faults, from one who shrank a $250 cashmere sweater to another
who "eschewed the organic products purchased online by her employer and instead
cleaned the whole apartment with industrial-strength bleach that made even the
cat’s eyes water." Yet since most of the characters are Manhattanites living in
a time when Lehman and Madoff had yet to fall (was that really less than a year
ago now?), the prurience that might once have tasted so sinfully sweet now
bears a bitter, even lurid aftertaste. I found myself wishing that Macy would
love her characters half as well as she knows them; at times, the fascination
that kept me riveted felt something akin to the suspense you feel when, stuck
in traffic on a highway, you spot the flashing blue lights ahead and realize
you're about to see the aftermath of a nasty accident. You know it’s already
happened, but you can’t help wanting to witness the mayhem. After all, who are
those strangers to you?

The Sweet By and By
by Todd Johnson '91MAR
William Morrow, $24.99
Reviewed by Janice P. Nimura '93
Janice Nimura '93 reviews books for the New York Times and other publications.
Todd Johnson’s debut novel is the
type that turns you into a casting director. His vivid ensemble of women, whose
shared link is a North Carolina nursing home, is a fresh take on steel
magnolias.
Elderly, elegant Margaret, frank and
cranky, could have been played by Jessica Tandy; Lorraine, Margaret's
unflappable and compassionate nurse, might make a nice role for Oprah. Then
there is Rhonda, a prickly hairdresser whose weekly visits to fix the hair of
the residents chip away at her emotional defenses. Toni Collette, maybe. The
youngest of the four narrators is April, Lorraine’s ambitious daughter, who has
exceeded her mother’s dreams by becoming a doctor. Halle Berry?
The Sweet By and By is a love story told in aphorisms.
That love can be maternal, romantic, spiritual, and sisterly. But too often, it
is expressed in treacly greeting-card sentiments that diminish Johnson's
wonderfully distinct characters. Would hard-partying Rhonda really declare,
"Faith to me is putting my heart where my hope is"? Does Lorraine need to tell
us that "Time heals, it’s true, but it don’t erase"?
Time, not plot, drives the story, an
unhurried meander past weddings and funerals, holidays and graduations, every
occasion deepening the comfort the women take in each other. Each finds her own
faith, and Johnson should have faith enough in them to let baser instincts
tarnish all those hearts of gold just a bit. Still, this is a diverting read. Someone should make a movie out of it.

Blindspot: A Novel by a Lady in Disguise & a Gentleman
in Exile
by Jane Kamensky '85, '93PhD, and Jill Lepore '9PhD
Spiegel and Grau/Random House, $27.95
Reviewed by Cathy Shufro
Cathy Shufro toils mightily as a writing tutor and lecturer
in the Department of English.
All prudence fled my house when this
Book entered. I cast aside my duties, I burned my candle low, in the reading of
it. The teller of this tale is a Scottish Face-Painter, dogged by debt, who
flees Edinburgh in 1764 for the Colony of Massachusetts-Bay. There the
gentleman employs an Apprentice yclept Edward Weston. The lad’s letters to a
bosom friend disclose that Edward Weston is, forsooth, Fanny Easton, a lady in
disguise.
Soon is their household enlarged by
the advent of an unredeemed captive, a genius. He vows to prove as murder the
mysterious death of a friend, a gentleman who has denounced slaveholding.
Contention abounds, for in the city upon the hill, the British yoke chafes.
Romance, too, soon enters the house:
though the painter seeks a Widow Bountiful, he finds himself distracted by a
stirring in his heart & loins for his apprentice, Edward (or, as the Reader
knows her to be, Fanny).
Not the story alone seduced me, but
word play most witty: riddles, puns, and quotations, and also other
play—carnal—that happily escaped the scrutiny of the Board of Censors.
The learned Reader might remark on
figures from True Life, for the two authors toiled in libraries, galleries,
archives &c. to build fiction inspir'd by Truth. Their researches surely
have merit, for they were apprenticed to scholars at Yale, that seat of
learning, and their novel honors a dear Professor, viz. John Demos. Now
themselves Professors of History close by Massachusetts-Bay, the authors remain
fast friends. This tale is the fruit of their labours, and O, dear Reader, what
pleasures await you!

The Magicians
by Lev Grossman '97MPhil
Viking, $26.95
Reviewed by Bruce Fellman
Bruce Fellman, managing editor of the Yale Alumni
Magazine, is an
aficionado of fantasy.
What would Harry Potter and his
mates have been like had they been able to finish Hogwarts, go on to a very
difficult and highly selective college of magic, and move to New York City? J.
K. Rowling’s celebrated (and copyrighted) characters do not make an appearance
in Lev Grossman’s classy and suspenseful fantasy tale, but there are plenty of
parallels.
Quentin, the angst-ridden,
brilliant, and socially inept 17-year-old protagonist, feels "cold all the
time, like he was trapped in his own private individual winter." But after a
college admissions interview goes badly wrong—the interviewer, an ancient
Princeton alum, turns up dead—Quentin somehow finds his way out of his hometown
in Brooklyn and into a thicket that leads him straight to a school called Brakebills.
This college isn’t in any higher-education guide—or, for that matter, on any
map—and any fan of Potter, Tolkien, or C. S. Lewis knows what’s coming.
Quentin and his fellow aspiring
magicians master all manner of spellcraft, turn into geese and randy foxes—in
this novel, there’s plenty of sex—play a brutal intercollegiate game called
Welters (alas, no broomsticks), and consume massive amounts of alcohol as they
stumble toward graduation.
Thanks to a magical trust fund, the
twentysomethings don’t have to work after leaving school and so pursue utterly
meaningless lives in Manhattan. But the lurch into Bright Lights, Big City territory is averted when Quentin
and company find a way into the pages of a fictional set of novels about a land
called Fillory. There, Quentin gets a chance to prove himself, as he and his
friends are pitted against a hideous, and hideously powerful, once-human beast
who has turned this gentle kingdom into Pyongyang. "We're going to Fillory,"
declares one of Quentin’s friends. "We have to. This is going to change
everything."  |
|