|
What's so funny about bugs?
July/August 2007
by David Wolman
May Berenbaum '75 is one of the most accomplished entomologists in the
country. Head of the Department of Entomology at University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign for 15 years, Berenbaum has earned numerous awards and
distinctions for teaching and research. She also has a sideline as, in her own
words, a PR person for insects." Her annual Insect Fear Film Festival is now
in its 25th year, and in 2000 she published her fourth book for lay readers, Buzzwords:
A Scientist Muses on Sex, Bugs, and Rock 'n' Roll.
Y: The mainstream media have gone bananas lately over honeybee colony
collapse disorder. What is CCD, exactly?
| |
The New York Times ran a story on honeybee colony collapse disorder. |
B: Basically, it's the precipitous disappearance of large numbers of
older adult bees from a colony for no known reason. Typically, individuals left
behind include a handful of young nurses tending to a healthy queen and
apparently healthy brood, along with seemingly adequate stores of honey and
pollen.
Y: The cause is still a mystery, correct?
B: Absolutely. Lots of people are working hard to figure it out, but it's
complicated for a number of reasons, not the least of which is because they're
a social species. Is it genetic or is it just the enormous stress of having
half of one's nest-mates gone? Bees know when half of the colony is gone. If
you woke up to find half of your home city missing, you'd know. That stress
could influence the bees' biology.
Y: What's the most preposterous explanation for CCD you've seen to
date?
B: Bee rapture. Yes -- as in all the bees are suddenly summoned back
to heaven. Oh, and alien abduction. Another person e-mailed me to say they were
killed on automobile grilles because of all the traffic. Contrails or chemical
trails from jetliners -- I don't really understand that one. Chernobyl was
another, and there was also genetically modified crops, and Osama bin Laden.
Actually, bin Laden did have an interest in a honey factory in Yemen at one
time.
Y: Insects have been in the news a lot recently.
B: Last year there was the paper about the honeybee genome in [the
journal] Nature, as well as the
National Academy of Sciences report on the state of pollinators. Soon after
that, honeybee colony collapse disorder was being investigated, and word was
getting out to the agriculture community. Then the New York Times ran a story on it. Now there's language in the Farm
Bill for pollinator protection. Which is just astonishing.
Y: When will entomologists stop being surprised about media coverage?
| |
I respect mosquitoes, but I don't like to room with them. |
B: Never. I write a column for the American Entomologist, sort of a humor column, or humorous among entomologists.
I wrote one on media coverage of CCD, collecting all the bee-related puns. I
sometimes wonder if they [the media] like this topic because of the endless fun
with headlines. Researchers Beefuddled," or Researchers Beemoan," and Bee
Very Afraid." Oh, there're just so many of them.
Y: Why has CCD resonated so strongly?
B: I think that the public cares because it's an environmental crisis
that's understandable. It doesn't require understanding of atmospheric
chemistry. It's birds and the bees; it's pollination! It's graspable.
Y: What's the concise version of your came-to-be-an-entomologist story?
And does Yale have any part in that script?
B: Yale is where I became an entomologist. I was always interested in
plants and animals. But I was an entomophobe as a kid, maybe from around age
seven. At Yale, I took Terrestrial Arthropods, taught by Charles Remington [who
died in May -- see Milestones]. I figured I could learn which insects I should
be afraid of.
Y: What's something you dislike about your job?
B: The tough part is undergrads that don't care. One of the classes I
teach is called Insects and People. It's a general education course. All of our
26,000 undergrads have to take three hours of life sciences to be well-rounded
people.
Y: Are you being sarcastic?
B: Yes.
Y: I once saw a clip in which the Dalai Lama spoke about loving all
creatures, including mosquitoes. As an entomologist, do you feel the same, or
is it kosher to detest mosquitoes?
B: Biologically, it's the microorganisms that mosquitoes carry that
harm humans. That said, I respect mosquitoes, but I don't like to room with
them.
Y: I imagine it'd be hard to be an entomologist without a sense of
humor.
B: It's true. If you look at entomology, it has enormous economic and
health impacts. Insect-borne disease is the leading cause of death for children
under five, and for disease-related death, malaria is like the number-one
killer. Yet people say: Oh! You study bugs," in this how-odd" tone of voice.
They assume you weren't properly socialized as a child. People accept that
microbiology is serious business. There's nothing funny about germs. But with
entomology, street cred doesn't come automatically. A sense of humor helps you
deal with that.
|