Comment on this article
In Print
Summer
2003
Brief
Reviews
Books Received
A
Personal Crusade
by Jennifer Kaylin
"You finally made it,"
says Samantha Power '92, opening the door to her shorefront condominium
in Winthrop, Massachusetts. With her long red hair loosely pulled
back in a low ponytail, and wearing gym shorts and a striped T-shirt,
Power looks more like a grad student packing up for summer vacation
than a celebrated scholar and the winner of the 2003 Pulitzer Prize
for nonfiction.
Power, a lecturer at
Harvard's Kennedy School of Government who spent more than five
years working on "A Problem from Hell": America and the Age of
Genocide, has little interest in appearances. She's finally
getting around to submitting a bill for travel expenses, so piles
of receipts are spread out on the living room floor. Her Robert
F. Kennedy Book Award bust stands by the wall, as though waiting
to be used as a doorstop. "I really need to find a place to put
that," she says. One item she has made sure to find a place for
is a Bosnian shell casing she uses as a flower vase; it stands in
the middle of her dining table. An ornate design was engraved in
the cylinder by an entrepreneurial shopkeeper who collected the
detritus of war and turned it into art.
If Power has scant
patience for domesticity, her commitment to human rights is boundless.
When her original publisher backed out of her book project, she
recalls, "you can't imagine how shell-shocked I was. I really believed
in it, so I was just stunned." Eventually Basic/New Republic Books
agreed to publish the manuscript, but it was a hard sell. "A lot
of people applaud the effort but don't want to open a book about
genocide," Power says. "I always say it's not a book about genocide;
that's just a useful lens to look at a century of American history
and the gap between our values and interests." She also sees the
book as a way to get readers to think about their own conduct. "If
you know there's domestic violence going on next door, do you get
involved or not?"
When Power started
college, she was a baseball fan who dreamed of becoming a sportscaster.
But while she was working in the sports department of an Atlanta
TV station, she had an epiphany that helped reshape her plans. "I
was editing the nightly sports roundup," she remembers. "Suddenly
on the TV monitor came raw footage of the student uprising in Tiananmen
Square, and I thought to myself, 'What am I doing with my life?'"
Power's growing concern
with matters beyond the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry led her to move
in 1993 to the former Yugoslavia, where she worked as a freelance
war correspondent for two years, filing stories for the Boston
Globe and U.S. News and World Report about the "ethnic
cleansing" of Muslims and Croats by Serb nationalists.
"I literally couldn't
believe what was going on," says Power, whose speech still carries
the slightest trace of her native Ireland. Equally shocking to her
was the United States' reluctance to do anything about it.
So she decided to write
a book. But despite her feelings about the carnage, Power knew it
would not be an angry one. "When you're writing something that carries
with it such high moral stakes, it's ineffective to tell people
something's wrong," she says. "It's better to muzzle my voice and
let readers debate it in their own heads."
As Power threw herself
into probing man's inhumanity to man -- while simultaneously attending
Harvard Law School -- the one indulgence she allowed herself was
baseball. "There's a rhythm to it. I'd build my day around the Red
Sox game," she says. "In between pitches I'd work on my transitions."
Now that the book is
done and the accolades are pouring in, Power knows she should probably
take some time off and unwind. But with everything that's going
on in the world, especially the AIDS pandemic in Africa, that's
unlikely. "I thought about writing about baseball," she says, "but
how can I? I feel so lucky that people actually want my thoughts
now. I have this window of opportunity and I need to take advantage
of it."

Anne Applebaum '86
Gulag:
A History
Doubleday, $35.00
Not long after Lenin
engineered the Soviet revolution of 1917, his fledgling government
began to create special prisons for "unreliable elements." In time,
the Gulag, as it was known, would become a "vast network of labor
camps that were once scattered across the length and breadth of
the Soviet Union, . from the Arctic Circle . to the Leningrad
suburbs," writes Anne Applebaum. In a riveting account of the infamous
prison system, the author builds on the foundation laid down by
Aleksandr I. Solzhenitsyn 30 years ago.
Applebaum, a Washington
Post columnist and a former correspondent with extensive experience
in Eastern Europe, draws on recently opened archives, a flood of
new memoirs, interviews with Gulag survivors, and trips to many
of the sites in what Solzhenitsyn called the "archipelago." The
result is a thorough -- the book is nearly 600 pages long, with
60 pages of notes and bibliography -- history of a repressive system
that "prisoners once called the 'meat-grinder': the arrests, the
interrogations, the transports in unheated cattle cars, the forced
labor, the destruction of families, the years spent in exile, the
early and unnecessary deaths."
But this is more than
a record of the Gulag's origins, growth, day-to-day workings, and
demise (in 1987 at the behest of Mikhail Gorbachev, the grandson
of Gulag prisoners). With a novelist's concern for character and
setting, Applebaum brings to life the grim system and its effect
on the estimated 18 million men, women, and children who went through
the camps between 1929 and 1953, their heyday during Stalin's rule.
Applebaum relates how,
after watching fellow inmates die from overwork, prisoners might
sever one of their own hands or feet as a means of survival. Others
refined the technique of tufta (pretending to work) or improved
their fate, and their daily rations, by serving as informants. But
a few also managed to preserve a measure of human dignity and altruism
despite suffering exhaustion, hunger, illness, brutality, and constant
death threats.
Nearly as horrifying
as prison life was the madly arbitrary basis for many arrests. People
landed here for telling a political joke or rebuffing an official's
amorous advances. There were even four prominent soccer players
who had made the mistake of defeating the favorite team of secret
police boss Lavrenty Beria. Applebaum cites a 1937 report setting
out arrest quotas for each republic -- 12,000 prisoners required
from Beloruss, 750 from Kirgiz, and so on.
The author explores
the strategic, political, and economic aspects of the Gulag, and
demonstrates how it emerged as a cornerstone of the Soviet system
and its economy. She also shows how those involved in the archipelago,
from administrators through prisoners, developed an idiosyncratic
culture with its own values, conventions, and language.
"This book was not
written 'so that it will not happen again,'" says Applebaum. "This
book was written because it almost certainly will happen again.
Totalitarian philosophies have had, and will continue to have, a
profound appeal to many millions of people . . . We need to know why
-- and each story, each memoir, each document in the history of
the Gulag is a piece of the puzzle, a part of the explanation."
-- Reviewed by David J. Baker '78PhD

Drew D. Hansen '00JD
The
Dream: Martin Luther King Jr. and the Speech that Inspired a Nation
Ecco/HarperCollins, $23.95
August 28, 1963, was
a sweltering day in Washington, D.C., but despite the weather, a
crowd of about 250,000 people jammed the Mall to protest racial
inequality. After many singers and speakers had finished, there
was one man left on the program: Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
King's "I have a dream"
speech, writes Drew Hansen, has become "the definitive statement
of the meaning of the civil rights revolution," and as Hansen shows,
its genius was the result of inspired improvisation. King, a minister
and fixture in the civil rights movement, opened his carefully written
address with a nod to Lincoln and a note that "one hundred years
later, the Negro is still not free." He went on to remind his Washington
audience that "America has given the Negro people a bad check."
There was "fierce urgency" in ensuring that "the bank of justice"
was not bankrupt.
But as King's talk
swelled to an eloquent conclusion, something unscripted happened.
"Behind him, Mahalia Jackson shouted, 'Tell them about the dream,
Martin!'" And after she repeated the request once more, King "left
his prepared text and began to preach," writes Hansen.
"[E]ven though we face
the difficulties of today and tomorrow, I still have a dream," said
King, beginning a seven-minutes-long extemporaneous masterpiece
whose words struck a deep chord that continues to resonate. The
end of the speech was crafted on the fly from set pieces -- King
had been using the "dream" set piece since 1962 -- in the preacher's
vast repertoire.
In a book similar to
historian Garry Wills's deconstruction, in Lincoln at Gettysburg, of the Emancipation Proclamation, Hansen examines the origin,
development, and impact of King's speech. The author does a fine
job of placing King in historical context, and Hansen's exploration
of the literary and religious traditions that King called on --
from anaphora (repeating a word or phrase) to the cadences
of the King James Bible, and from parallelism to prophecy -- is
fascinating.
Of particular value
is Hansen's account of the aftermath of the speech and the not-always-successful
campaigns King led until his assassination in 1968. The author also
follows the speech to the present, where it has been the foundation
for an "astonishing transformation of America" and, ironically enough,
it has also been invoked as a justification for opposing affirmative
action.
Of course, the dream
remains unfulfilled. "King's legacy is the gift of prophecy," writes
Hansen, "a vision of what a redeemed America might look like, and
a hope that this redemption will one day come to pass."
--
Reviewed by Bruce Fellman

Brief
Reviews
Jessica Helfand '82,
'89MFA
Reinventing
the Wheel
Princeton Architectural Press, $24.95
Before the
invention of the computer, people created paper wheels that could
be used for everything from finding the position of stars to calculating
fertility. Graphic designer and volvelle collector Helfand
offers a beautiful look at these often remarkable devices.
Lloyd Kaufman '69
Make Your Own Damn Movie! Secrets of a Renegade Director
St. Martin's Griffin, $14.95
The creator
of The Toxic Avenger, Tromeo and Juliet, and more than two
dozen other films provides an irreverent guide to making the kinds
of independent films that Hollywood doesn't.
Mary Jane Minkin
'75MD, Clinical Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology, and Carol
V. Wright
The Yale Guide to Women's Reproductive Health: From Menarche
to Menopause
Yale University Press, $29.95
Authoritative
and easy-to-understand answers to a wide range of gynecological
questions.
Tricia Rose '84
Longing to Tell: Black Women Talk about Sexuality and
Intimacy
Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, $25.00
While there
is an abundance of narrative material about sex, little of it relates
to black women. Sociologist Rose explains why such a paucity exists
and presents a wealth of storytellers who relate their most intimate
lives.
Henry Ruth '52 and
Kevin R. Reitz
The Challenge of Crime: Rethinking Our Response
Harvard University Press, $35.00
A meticulous
survey of the last 30 years of American criminal justice offers
a stinging indictment of the present system and a series of rational
reforms.
Calvin Trillin '57
Feeding a Yen: Savoring Local Specialties, From Kansas City
to Cuzco
Random House, $22.95
Desperately
seeking such foods as magic bagels, pan bagnats, ceviche, and boudin,
Trillin recounts his adventures roaming the world in search of the
perfect nosh.

Books
Received
Antoinette
Burton 1983, Editor
After the Imperial Turn: Thinking With and Through the Nation
Duke University Press, $69.95
Brent Hayes Edwards
1990
The Practice of Diaspora: Literature, Translation, and the Rise
of Black Internationalism
Harvard University Press, $55.00
Leslie Epstein 1960,
1967DFA
San Remo Drive: A Novel, from Memory
Handsel Books/Other Press, $24.00
Stephen Gorman 1988MES
Northeastern Wilds: Journeys of Discovery in the Northern Forest
Appalachian Mountain Club Books, $39.95
Jake Halpern 1997
Braving Home: Dispatches from the Underwater Town, the Lava-Side
Inn, and Other Extreme Locales
Houghton Mifflin, $23.00
Ken Howard 1969Dra
Act Natural: How to Present Your Best Self in Public
Random House, $24.95
William Maynard Hutchins
1964
Tawfiq al-Hakim: A Reader's Guide
Lynne Rienner Publishers, $49.95
Teresa Jordan 1977
Field Notes from Yosemite: Apprentice to Place
Johnson Books, $16.00
Jake Kosek 1995MES, Donald S. Moore, and Anand Pandian, Editors
Race, Nature, and the Politics of Difference
Duke University Press, $74.95
Richard Krevolin
1986
How to Adapt Anything Into a Screenplay
John Wiley and Sons, $15.95
Patrick B. Miller
1972
The Unlevel Playing Field: A Documentary History of the African
American Experience in Sport
University of Illinois Press, $39.95
Paula A. Monopoli
1980
American Probate: Protecting the Public, Improving the Process
Northeastern University Press, $28.95
Bruce Moody 1954
Will Work for Food or $: A Memoir from the Roadside
Red Wheel Press, $24.95
Laura Morelli 1998PhD
Made in Italy: A Shopper's Guide to the Best of Italian Tradition
Rizzoli/Universe, $24.95
Jim Rogers 1964
Adventure Capitalist: The Ultimate Investor's Road Trip
Random House, $27.50
Molly Anne Rothenberg
1974, Dennis A. Foster, and Slavoj Zizek, Editors
Perversion and the Social Relation: Sic 4
Duke University Press, $59.95
Sam Rubin 1995
Baseball in New Haven
Arcadia/Tempus, $19.99
Peter H. Schuck,
Simeon E. Baldwin Professor of Law
Diversity in America: Keeping Government at a Safe Distance
Harvard University Press, $35.00
Thomas A. Schweich
1982
Staying Power: 30 Secrets Invincible Executives Use for Getting
to the Top -- And Staying There
McGraw-Hill, $14.95
Roger L. Simon 1970MFA
Director's Cut: A Moses Wine Novel
Atria Books/Simon and Schuster, $23.00
Jeremi Suri 2001PhD
Power and Protest: Global Revolution and the Rise of Detente
Harvard University Press, $29.95
Christopher Torchia
1989 and Sang-Hun Choe
How Koreans Talk: A Collection of Expressions
Unhengnamu, 8,000 won
John Philip Trinkaus,
Professor Emeritus of Biology
Embryologist: My Eight Decades in Developmental Biology
J&S Publishing, $49.95
Jennifer Vanderbes
1996
Easter Island
Dial Press, $24.95 |