Comment on this article
In Print
October
2002
Brief
Reviews
Books Received
Richard Conniff '73
The
Natural History of the Rich: A Field Guide
W.W.
Norton, $26.95
It is an old question:
Are the rich different from the rest of us? In the course of his
research Richard Conniff was told by a stockbroker, "We're all the
same beast, with or without the Cartier." But the author suggests
that it ain't necessarily so.
While all human beings
belong to the same species, "the dynamic of being rich sets people
apart," and this, says Conniff, "isolates them from the general
population, the first step in any evolutionary process, and it inexorably
causes them to become different. Thus, from the primordial muck,
something new and wondrous emerges: a cultural subspecies, Homo
sapiens pecuniosus. "
Conniff, a writer specializing
in natural history, turns a naturalist's eye on the wealthy and
uses the latest findings from evolutionary biology to document how
rich people have come to occupy a dominant part of the economic
food chain. The result of his research is by turns funny and revealing
as the writer, who has stalked grizzlies, climbs into a rented "bright
red Ferrari F355 Spider convertible worth $150,000" and, duly camouflaged,
seeks out "a new quarry," people who were "possibly the most dangerous
and elusive animals on Earth."
The writer survives
-- so does the car -- and emerges with a wealth of observations
of the rich as he explores such topics as gift-giving, "the service
heart," risk-taking, "inconspicuous consumption," and, of course,
sex. Conniff also uses discoveries from animal behaviorists to show
how the ways of the natural world might play out in the world of
the well-to-do.
The experience of hobnobbing
with the monied elite enabled the author to create "An Alpha Ape's
Ten Rules for Living Wisely in an Imperfect World." Following them
may not guarantee a fortune, but they could make life easier for
wealthy and wannabe alike.
-- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Steven
R. Weisman '68
The
Great Tax Wars: Lincoln to Wilson -- The Fierce Battles Over Money
and Power that Transformed the Nation
Simon
and Schuster, $27.00
In 1861 President Abraham
Lincoln was confronted with a bleak reality: Fighting a war to preserve
the Union would cost a fortune. Where it would come from was uncertain.
"Money!" said Lincoln. "I don't know anything about 'money.'"
Most of the federal
government's revenue came from tariffs on imported goods, but this
source would not cover the expenses of a lengthy conflict. So the
president turned to something new.
"On July 1, 1862, Lincoln
signed the first federal income tax in United States history," notes New York Times writer Steven R. Weisman. "It was a momentous
piece of legislation . [and] it established what until then was
considered a revolutionary principle: the idea of taxing rich people
at a higher rate compared to the rate for people less well off."
While that principle
was, with the adoption of the 16th Amendment in 1913, made a lasting
part of the U.S. Constitution, the income tax has had a rocky history.
And, in the hands of Weisman, a remarkably entertaining one rich
with controversy and larger-than-life characters. "From 1860 to
1920, the era of the great tax wars resounded with arguments over
two definitions of fairness," he writes. The first was "that it
was fair for society to tax income at graduated rates"; the second
"held that it was not only fair but also vital to the spirit of
free enterprise to allow citizens to keep the wealth they earned."
Resolving these two seemingly irreconcilable positions remains a
challenge.
-- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Frank Clifford '67
The Backbone
of the World: A Portrait of a Vanishing Way of Life Along the Continental
Divide
Broadway
Books, $24.95
The Continental Divide
Trail is an as-yet uncompleted 3,100-mile path that more or less
follows the crest of the Rocky Mountains from Mexico to Canada.
Several years ago, Frank Clifford, an environmental journalist with
the Los Angeles Times, "lit out" to sample sections of the
trail and see if he could find "traces of that old world of remote
ranches . mule packers, gyppos, trappers, prospectors, and range
riders."
Along the way, Clifford
discovered many people with strong ties to the land. But the author
is no sentimentalist, and the portraits he presents are less about
"mythopolis" -- the western wilderness in which people go "to reconnect
with their dreams" -- than a west filled with very different ideas
about the best way to use the natural environment.
No one Clifford profiles
is out of central casting. For example, a conversation around a
fire with a group of Blackfeet Indian elders doesn't quite go as
planned. "I suppose you thought we were going to sit here and tell
a bunch of old, old stories about how Napi and them other gods traipsed
around these mountains?" one of the elders asks. "'Cause I don't
know any of them stories."
So much for stereotypes,
and many of the tales Clifford relates are similar in spirit. This
is less "Rocky Mountain High" than an engaging look at characters
with conflicts, residents of a Divide, both literal and metaphorical,
that is "animated by feuds -- between cowboys and conservationists,
sheepherders and coyotes, wolves and elk," Clifford notes. "And
it would be a lesser place for the loss of any of the antagonists."
-- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Tom Stone '58
The
Summer of My Greek Taverna: A Memoir
Simon
and Schuster, $24.00
"There are places that
seem to be waiting for you out there somewhere, like unmet lovers,
and when (and if) you come upon them, you know, instantly and unquestioningly,
that they are the ones."
So Tom Stone, author
of The Summer of My Greek Taverna, feels about the unspoiled
Greek island of Patmos. Thus, when he, his wife (whom he had met
on the island), and children had to leave for the unromantic reason
of financial hardship, it seemed like the end of the affair.
That is, until one
dreary morning in the Cretan city Rethymnon. Tom's mad rush to his
job of teaching English is interrupted by a phone call from his
Patmian friend, Theologos, who asks if he would like to rent his
cafe for the summer. It is an offer Tom cannot refuse, believing
he can make enough money in one summer to allow him to write and
his wife to paint for the rest of the year.
Ignoring warnings to
beware of Greeks bearing gifts -- especially a Greek whose nickname
is O Lados (The Oily One) -- Tom packs up the family and
heads to Patmos to take charge of "The Beautiful Helen."
Reminiscent of Peter
Mayle's A Year in Provence, this memoir (which also includes
Tom's favorite recipes) begins with what seems like a stroke of
luck, and unfolds as a series of entanglements, not least of which
is Tom's realization that Theologos is cheating him. Misfortunes
aside, the book serves as Tom's love note for the island, its people,
and his wife, who stayed by his side as he followed an impossible
dream.
-- Reviewed
by Jennifer L. Holley

Victor Brombert '48,
'53PhD
Trains of
Thought: Memories of a Stateless Youth
W.W.
Norton, $25.95
Undergraduates by the
score attended the lecture courses of Professor Victor Brombert,
head of the prestigious Yale French department in the 1960s and early 1970s. As I can testify from graduate school days -- I was
a teaching assistant in his course, "The Art of the Novel in France"
-- he taught more than the French masters. Brombert personified
Gallic brilliance (that ability to spot similarities and disparities
where least expected) while demonstrating the deepest awe for literary
creativity and the life of the mind.
Born in 1923, the debonair
scholar enjoyed a pampered youth in the chic 16th Arrondissement
of Paris in the 1930s, traveled widely, and grew up speaking French,
German, and Russian. The book's title echoes the recurring theme
of travel, for pleasure and sometimes for survival. (He arrived
in the U.S. in 1941 as a refugee onboard an "absurdly overcrowded
and unhygienic freighter.") Brombert also presents vivid recollections
of the fall of France, life under the Vichy government in the non-occupied
zone, and his family's hair-raising flight to freedom abroad.
Former students will
recognize the author's voice: his fondness for metaphor, etymology,
ambiguity, and wide-ranging allusion. However, the young man he
describes -- unflinchingly -- seems more alien. The teen-aged Brombert
of Paris days emerges as a vain slacker, obsessed with popular entertainment,
clothes, and especially women; he shows no signs of an inclination
towards a literary vocation.
But then comes the
war and his need to gain a foothold in the new world. At Yale, Brombert
modeled himself after French professor Henri Peyre, and in this
memoir, written in the tradition of the coming-of-age novels so
brilliantly explored in Brombert's French 58, we observe a resilient
young man's struggle toward awareness and commitment.
-- Reviewed
by David
Baker '78PhD

Brief Reviews
Elizabeth
Grossman '78
Watershed: The Undamming
of America
Counterpoint,
$27.00
There are more than 75,000 dams in this country, but in recent years,
an increasing number have been removed from the nation's waterways.
Journalist Grossman chronicles the growth of an environmental movement
to return rivers and streams to their natural state.
Jessica
Francis Kane '93
Bending Heaven
Counterpoint,
$23.00
In 11 gem-like stories, the author invents and explores melancholy
worlds in which her characters -- a writer, a mother, a mathematician,
a lawyer, among them -- struggle quietly but heroically to make
sense of lives that don't ever quite work.
Stuart
Miller and Geoffrey Moss '62BFA, '64MFA
The Biker Code: Wisdom for the Ride
Simon
and Schuster, $12.95
From "Road Kill," "Amazing Grace," and other bikers, Miller and
Moss have gleaned photos and aphorisms: "For some there's therapy.
For the rest of us, there's motorcycles." Ride on.
Ralph
J. Roberts '49PhD
A Passion for Gold: An Autobiography
University
of Nevada Press, $29.95
The author's career with the U.S. Geological Survey and as a private
consultant took him around the world, from the mountains of Nevada
to what may have been King Solomon's mines in Saudi Arabia. Roberts
tells the story of a man who really struck gold.
Rebecca
J. Tannenbaum '96PhD
The Healer's Calling: Women and Medicine in Early New England
Cornell
University Press, $34.95
Doctors in 17th- and 18th-century New England were more likely female
than male. Historian Tannenbaum describes the medical practices
of these healers.
Harlow Giles Unger
'53
Lafayette
John
Wiley and Sons, $30.00
In a compelling biography, Unger brings to life the French nobleman
who became a hero of the American Revolution -- "the Conqueror of
Cornwallis" -- and an enemy of the state when he tried to introduce
democracy to France.

Books
Received
Michele
Mckay Aynesworth 1972MA, Translator
Mad Toy, by Roberto Arlt
Duke
University Press, $15.95
Carol Baicker-McKee
1980
FussBusters On the Go: Around-the-Clock Strategies and Games
for Smoothing the Rough Spots in Your Preschooler's Day
Peachtree
Publishing, $15.95
Joel Bernstein 1967PhD
Polymorphism in Molecular Crystals
Oxford
University Press, $125.00
Jeff Diamant 1994
Heist! The $17 Million Loomis Fargo Theft
John
F. Blair, Publisher, $24.95
Peter X Feng 1988
Identities in Motion: Asian American Film and Video
Duke
University Press, $19.95
Peter H. Gleick
1978BS, Writer and Editor
The World's Water 2002-2003: The Biennial Report on Freshwater
Resources
Island
Press, $32.50
Paul Edward Gottfried
1967PhD
Multiculturalism and the Politics of Guilt
University
of Missouri Press, $29.95
Gregory Hays 1991,
Translator
Meditations, by Marcus Aurelius
Modern
Library, $19.95
John R. Knott 1959
Imagining Wild America
University
of Michigan Press, $55.00
James Lengel 1971
The Web Wizard's Guide to Multimedia
Addison-Wesley,
$26.00
Brian Lepard 1989JD
Rethinking Humanitarian Intervention: A Fresh Legal Approach
Based on Fundamental Ethical Principles in International Law and
World Religions
Penn
State Press, $55.00
Florencia E. Mallon
1980PhD, Editor and Translator
When a Flower Is Reborn: The Life and Times of a Mapuche Feminist,
Rosa Isolde Reuque Paillalef
Duke
University Press, $59.95
Leonard S. Marcus
1972
Ways of Telling: Conversations on the Art of the Picture Book
Dutton,
$29.99
J. D. McClatchy
1974PhD, Editor
Horace, the Odes: New Translations by Contemporary Poets
Princeton
University Press, $24.95
David F. Musto, 1961MA,
Professor of the History of Medicine, and Professor of Child Psychiatry,
and Pamela Korsmeyer
The Quest for Drug Control: Politics and Federal Policy in a
Period of Increasing Substance Abuse, 1960-1980
Yale
University Press, $35.00
Benjamin Nathans
1984
Beyond the Pale: The Jewish Encounter with Late Imperial Russia
University
of California Press, $54.95
Jim Ostheimer 1955
Blue Yonder
The
Grimmet Press, $14.95
Eileen Pollack 1978BS
Woman Walking Ahead: In Search of Catherine Weldon and Sitting
Bull
University
of New Mexico Press, $29.95
Francesca Polletta
1994PhD
Freedom Is An Endless Meeting: Democracy in American Social Movements
University
of Chicago Press, $35.00
Elizabeth A. Povinelli
1991PhD
The Cunning of Recognition: Indigenous Alterities and the Making
of Australian Multiculturalism
Duke
University Press, $21.95
Martha Sandweiss
1985PhD
Print the Legend: Photography and the American West
Yale
University Press, $39.95
Joan Sullivan 1995
An American Voter: My Love Affair with Presidential Politics
Bloomsbury,
$23.95
Mark Taylor 1961
Shakespeare's Imitations
University
of Delaware Press, $35.00
Jessica Warner 1991PhD
Craze: Gin and Debauchery in an Age of Reason
Four
Walls Eight Windows, $24.95
Stacy Wolf 1983
A Problem Like Maria: Gender and Sexuality in the American Musical
University
of Michigan Press, $49.50 |