| |
|
Previous
Columns
May
2002 Good and bad news; shopping trip; family plot.
April
2002 Travels with cranes; landscape history; Jack the
Ripper.
March
2002 September 11 analysis; coming home; the Zen of parking.
February
2002 Evolution exlored; an asylum for the well-off; dream
poems.
December
2001 Smallpox, past and disturbing present; a history
of duels.
November
2001 Corsets; legal malpractice; poems inspired by art.
October
2001 Rescue mission; art poems.
Summer
2001 Adams insights; gene secrets.
May
2001 The Bible as Baedeker; CEOs talk modern strategy;
a western woman explores Iran.
April
2001 Med School dean tackles tobacco; surving a famous
father; campaign bad manners.
February
2001 A nun's dilemma; pictorial history; parasites revealed.
December
2000 An old bar mitzvah; searching for dad; a harem fantasy.
November
2000
Women in math and science; a week watching television.
October
2000 Spinning memories; spuds and sculpture; life after
duel.
|
|
|
In Print
Summer
2002
Brief
Reviews
Books Received
Maria
Rosa Menocal, Director of the Whitney Humanities Center
The
Ornament of the World: How Muslims, Jews, and Christians Created
A Culture of Tolerance in Medieval Spain
Little,
Brown and Company, $26.95
Almost
every morning dawns with more bad news from the Middle East: the
latest suicide bombing, the inevitable counterstroke, the unholy
calls by one side or another to rid the area -- the Holy Land, by
another name -- of foes who can never again be trusted. It is a
depressingly ancient tale that is being played out in many parts
of the modern world, but though stories from such places as Sarajevo
and, more recently, New York, Washington, and Pennsylvania, would
suggest that Muslims, Jews, and Christians simply can't get along,
the animosity has not always been a part of history.
"Once
upon a time in the mid-eighth century, an intrepid young man named
Abd al-Rahman abandoned his home in Damascus, the Near Eastern heartland
of Islam, and set out across the North African desert in search
of a place of refuge." So begins this remarkable look by historian
Maria Rosa Menocal, professor of Spanish and Portuguese, at the
empire the exile founded in what is now Spain -- an empire that
flourished for some seven centuries and was characterized by the
rarest of commodities: religious tolerance. Indeed, when a tenth-century
Saxon writer named Hroswitha described Cordoba, the city al-Rahman
adopted as his home, she coined the term "the ornament of the world"
to characterize a cultural symbiosis that would make the region
then known as Andalusia a center of science, poetry, philosophy,
and architecture in a world generally beset with intellectual darkness.
Andalusia
was, says Menocal, a "first- rate" place, "in the sense of F. Scott
Fitzgerald's wonderful formula (laid out in his essay "The Crack
Up") -- namely, that 'the test of a first-rate intelligence is the
ability to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time.'
In its moments of great achievement, medieval culture positively
thrived on holding at least two, and often many more, contrary ideas
at the same time."
Menocal
traces how the "cultivation of the complexities, charms, and challenges
of contradictions -- of the 'yes and no'" developed and flourished
into a "whole series of golden ages" whose echoes are still present
today. The writer also grapples with how this climate of tolerance
disappeared and what its demise means for our own efforts to recreate
a kind of Andalusia.
-- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Stephen
L. Carter '79JD, William Nelson Cromwell professor of Law
The
Emperor of Ocean Park
Alfred
A. Knopf, $26.95
Erle
Stanley Gardner, Scott Turow, and John Grisham are a few of the
lawyers who have used the the legal profession as grist for page-turning
thrillers, and with the publication of his first novel this month,
Stephen L. Carter, the William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Law,
joins that storied group of writers. Carter is certainly no stranger
to the literary world, and in seven nonfiction books and numerous
articles, the law professor has become one of the leading "public
intellectuals."
But
while his explorations of such issues as values, integrity, religious
freedom, and constitutional law have made him a fixture on op-ed
pages and high-brow talk shows, the recent appearance of The
Emperor of Ocean Park has been one of the most talked-about
events of the literary season. Bought by publisher Alfred A. Knopf
for $4.2 million as part of a two-novel package, the book represents
an almost unpredecented vote of confidence in a first-time novelist.
And
in many ways, Carter delivers.
The
big (657 pages), wide-ranging story tells of a family patriarch
with a messy secret, and a son's efforts to learn it. "My father
died at his desk," he writes. "And, at first, only my sister and
a few stoned callers to late-night radio shows believed he had been
murdered."
Judge
Oliver Garland had gained notoriety when his nomination to the Supreme
Court collapsed in scandal, and when he died suddenly several years
later -- apparently of a heart attack -- the Judge left to his son
Talcott, who
teaches law at a prominent university in the fictional town of Elm
Harbor, a puzzle in which chess and shadows would figure prominently.
The author is adept at moving his characters around Washington,
the law school, the elite black neighborhoods of Martha's Vineyard,
and other spots on a well-drawn chessboard, and Carter has mastered
the staccato zingers that make this genre so compelling.
"Did
you know that Daddy owned a gun?" Talcott is asked by his sister,
who was going through the Judge's belongings and found something
unexpected. "It was in a box with. well, with some bullets . . .
It's been fired, Tal. Recently."
But
this novel is more than a mere pot-boiler. Carter also offers an
engaging portrait of a family and the way the Judge's secret has
played out in their lives. The result is a literary hybrid, a book
that has echoes of both John Grisham and Leo Tolstoy -- and is a
memorable debut.
-- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Stuart
Banner '85
The
Death Penalty: An American History
Harvard
University Press, $29.95
In
1821 in Salem, Massachusetts, Stephen Clark stood on the gallows,
lowered his head for the hangman's noose, and without a word, stoically
accepted his fate. Executed for arson, Clark was all of 16 years
old.
But
while there had been hangings before -- the colonists adopted the
laws of a country with a long list of capital offenses -- Clark's
case would spark a debate on the morality of execution. "Because
of his death sentence, Clark dangled in public memory far longer
than he had lived on earth," says Stuart Banner, a professor of
legal history at the Washington University School of Law. "He was
not the first person converted into a debating point after having
been punished with death, and he would certainly not be the last."
In
a fascinating and macabre book, Banner describes how the death penalty
has been applied throughout U.S. history and how its role has changed.
"Capital punishment could command widespread support in the 17th
and 18th centuries as a punishment for all serious crimes because
it served three important purposes," notes the author. These were
deterrence, retribution, and penitence.
To
best accomplish these goals, executions were public events. But
as new ways of looking at crime and punishment, as well as new technologies
for meting out the ultimate penalty, began to hold sway, executions
moved indoors into more and more private settings, such as the hospital
room-like atmosphere in which lethal injection, today's dominant
method, takes place.
The
debate over the morality of capital punishment, however, remains
highly public. Banner presents a thoroughly readable account of
the legal history and the issues, particularly the question of the
possibility of executing innocent people, that have led us to the
present state of affairs.
-- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Richard
Lingeman '59LAW
Sinclair
Lewis: Rebel from Main Street
Random
House, $35.00
The
ambitious, protean quality of Sinclair Lewis (1885-1951) -- author
of iconic American works like Babbitt, Main Street,
Elmer Gantry, and Arrowsmith -- eludes the grasp of
standard biography. It would take a novelist, one like Lewis himself,
to encompass the man's satiric vision, his political and artistic
passions, and the improbable arc of a career that included the Nobel
Prize for Literature in 1930 and a series of hellish alcoholic binges.
Still,
the facts themselves make a fascinating story, both of a celebrity
author and of America in the first half of the 20th century. Lingeman
(author of a Theodore Dreiser biography as well) shows how much
Lewis belonged to his place and time, with his zest for aviation
and automobiles and interest in social issues like female suffrage
and racial integration. His sociopolitical satire won him praise
abroad, along with resentment at home. To his publishers' delight,
each new novel, during his peak years, generated not just favorable
reviews but newspaper headlines and massive sales.
Pockmarked
and insecure, Lewis felt like a misfit at Yale (Class of 1907),
and later in bohemian Greenwich Village and in artist colonies on
both coasts. He alternated sprees and binges with periods of hard
work, including year-long research missions to prepare each of the
major novels. He changed residences constantly, ignored his sons,
divorced twice, and alienated a vast circle of friends, including
H.L. Mencken. Even when inspiration failed him, the act of writing
remained a physical need.
Following
decades of critical disfavor, this appreciative biography recognizes
Lewis's impact on American realist fiction and social criticism.
"We've all known a Babbitt, an Elmer Gantry, a Gopher Prairie,"
Lingeman writes. "His portrayals, out of another age, live on, larger
than life."
-- Reviewed
by David J. Baker '78PhD

Stephen
Sandy '55
Surface
Impressions
Louisiana
State University Press, $24.95
Stephen
Sandy's latest book, a long poem called Surface Impressions,
has designs on making sense of a world where transitory moments,
such as losing one's hat to the wind, must be negotiated with "eternity
that great white." The latter, Sandy writes, is "a little . much."
So, he decides to stay focused on the here and now : "I'm taking
/ them as they come, these thoughts like skipping stones / that
trip along the water till they fizzle, / sinking."
The
stream of musings, ranging from punchy to poignant, touches upon
family and strangers, companionship and isolation, civilization
and nature. The whole of this conflicted, harmonious, battered,
and life-giving world is welcomed heartily into the lives explored
in this poetry. Of a son who is embarking on his first road trip
and about to face the wideness of the world for the first time,
Sandy says, "Home is where you leave from / and soon he'll be on
his way to all the space / he is a part of."
While
oblivion may be inevitable, it can be delayed by a full acceptance
of living. As with skipping a stone, the joy is in just how far
you can take it before it sinks -- and Sandy is a champion skipper.
-- Reviewed
by By
Jennifer L. Holley

Brief Reviews
Roberta
Baker '79
No Ordinary Olive
Little,
Brown, $14.95
"When Olive Elizabeth Julia Jerome was born, she cried louder
than any other baby," writes Baker. In this charming story for children
and adults alike, Baker follows Olive's extraordinary adventures
and highlights the power of imagination.
Alvin Kernan '54PhD
The Fruited Plain: Fables for a Postmodern Democracy
Yale
University Press, $24.95
In Kernan's satire, the beleaguered Joad family from Steinbeck's
Grapes of Wrath returns to migrate out of California and
straight into all the cultural excesses of America at the start
of the new millennium.
Steve
Olson '78
Mapping Human History: Discovering the Past through Our Genes
Houghton
Mifflin, $25.00
Science journalist Olson describes how new discoveries about DNA
are being used to uncover the story of human prehistory, to trace
our migration out of Africa, and to debunk divisive notions about
race.
Ann
Packer '81
The Dive from Clausen's Pier
Alfred
A. Knopf, $24.00
In a powerful debut novel, Carrie's fiance Mike is paralyzed in
a swimming accident. The young woman must confront difficult and
often painful questions about allegiances, the meaning of home,
and whether it's a sign of strength or weakness to walk away from
someone in need.
Bryan
Mark Rigg '96
Hitler's Jewish Soldiers: The Untold Story of Nazi Racial Laws and
Men of Jewish Descent in the German Military
University
Press of Kansas, $29.95
Historian Rigg offers a provocative account of the Mischlinge,
men of partial Jewish heritage who nevertheless served in the Nazi
military.
Alexander
Stille '78
The Future of the Past
Farrar,
Straus, and Giroux, $25.00
Technological innovations are making it more possible than ever
to understand and preserve the past, and yet, says journalist Stille
in this fascinating and troubling book, technology is paradoxically
accelerating its destruction.

Books
Received
Louis
Daniel Brodsky 1963
Shadow War: A Poetic Chronicle of September 11 and Beyond, Volumes
One,
Two,
and Three
Time Being Books, $12.50 each
Colette Brooks 1978MFA
In the City: Random Acts of Awareness
W.W.
Norton, $23.95
Alan Dundes 1955,
1958MA
The Shabbat Elevator and other Sabbath Subterfuges: An Unorthodox
Essay on Circumventing Custom and Jewish Character
Rowman
and Littlefield, $21.95
David Whitcomb Gow
1945
Gow: A Father, a Son, a School
Posterity
Press, $30.00
Elizabeth Grossman
1978
Watershed: The Undamming of America
Counterpoint
Press, $27.00
Philip Hamburger
1982JD
Separation of Church and State
Harvard
University Press, $49.95
Benjamin Harshav,
J. and H. Blaustein Professor of Hebrew and Comparative Literature,
Editor, and Barbara Harshav, Lecturer in Comparative Literature,
Translator
The Last Days of the Jerusalem of Lithuania: Chronicles from
the Vilna Ghetto and the Camps, 1939-1944, by Herman Kruk
Yale
University Press, $39.95
Richard E. Henrich
Jr. 1969, Translator
Love Making Visits (L'Amour en visites), by Alfred Jarry
electricUmbrella
Publishing, $15.95
Daniel Karasik 1945
The New Spring
Xlibris
Books, $21.99
Stephen R. Kellert
1971PhD, Tweedy Ordway Professor of Social Ecology, and Peter H.
Kahn Jr., Editors
Children and Nature: Psychological, Sociocultural, and Evolutionary
Investigations
MIT
Press, $60.00
Robert C. King 1948BS,
1952PhD, and William D. Stansfield
A Dictionary of Genetics: Sixth Edition
Oxford
University Press, $49.95
Edward Lee 1996BS,
1996MS, William Berkowitz, Babak Razani, Steven Wang, and Jennifer
Wu
OrgoCards: Organic Chemistry Review
Barron's,
$18.95
John P. McCormick,
Assistant Professor of Political Science, Editor
Confronting Mass Democracy and Industrial Technology: Political
and Social Theory from Nietzsche to Habermas
Duke
University Press, $21.95
Wayne A. Meeks 1965PhD,
Woolsey Professor Emeritus of
Religious Studies, and Allen R. Hilton 1997PhD, Assistant Professor
of New Testament, and H. Gregory Snyder, Editors
In Search of the Early Christians: Selected Essays, Wayne A.
Meeks
Yale
University Press, $35.00
Geoffrey Moss 1962BFA,
1964MFA, Photographer, and Stuart Miller
The Biker Code: Wisdom for the Ride
Simon
and Schuster, $12.95
Edgar M. Nash 1948BS
The Court-Martial of Ensign Mason
1stBooks
Library, $15.95
Robert Reich 1991
Bridging Liberalism and Multiculturalism in American Education
University
of Chicago Press, $21.00
Lawrence Schimel
1993, Editor
Found Tribe: Jewish Coming Out Stories
Sherman
Asher Publishing, $15.95
Susan M. Schultz
1980
Memory Cards and Adoption Papers
Potes
and Poets Press, $12.95
Charles Scott 1961BD,
1965PhD
The Lives of Things
Indiana
University Press, $49.95
Shawn C. Smallman
1995PhD
Fear and Memory in the Brazilian Army and Society, 1889-1954
University
of North Carolina Press, $49.95
Roger P. Smith 1952
The Other Face of Public TV: Censoring the American Dream
Algora
Publishing, $29.95
Carol M. Swain 2000MSL
The New White Nationalism in America: Its Challenge to Integration
Cambridge
University Press, $30.00
John V. Tolan 1981
Saracens: Islam in the Medieval European Imagination
Columbia
University Press, $52.50
John Alexander Williams
1966PhD
Appalachia: A History
University
of North Carolina Press, $19.95
|
|