Comment on this article
In Print
February
2002
Brief
Reviews
Books Received
Alex
Beam '75
Gracefully
Insane: The Rise and Fall of America's Premier Mental Hospital
PublicAffairs/Perseus
Books, $26.00
In
his poem, "Waking in the Blue," Robert Lowell described the "thoroughbred
mental cases" with whom he spent time as a patient at McLean Hospital.
The venerable psychiatric institution just outside Boston opened
its doors in 1817, and by the start of the Civil War, it was treating
a specialty clientele -- the "Mayflower screwballs," in the words
of Lowell -- the mentally ill members of Boston society.
Alex
Beam, a columnist for the Boston Globe, offers a look at
McLean and its residents, from two brothers of Ralph Waldo Emerson
to sibling folksingers James, Livingston, and Kate Taylor. Ray Charles
spent time there, as did a group of writers Beam called "the mad
poets' society" -- Lowell, Sylvia Plath, and Anne Sexton.
McLean
housed so many Harvard men that one building, the palatial Upham
Memorial, was dubbed the "Harvard Club." And Yale was prominently
represented by Carl Liebman, Class of 1922, a patient of Sigmund
Freud. When Liebman died in 1969, he had been at McLean for half-a-century
and had received "every form of treatment known to homo psychiatricus, "
says Beam. However, despite psychoanalysis, electroshock, hydrotherapy,
and a minilobotomy, the "Man Who Knew Freud" was never cured.
In
fact, Beam portrays the hospital as sometimes little more than a
well-appointed, well-landscaped (Frederick Law Olmsted, also a patient,
designed the place), and well-meaning custodian of the worried and
wacky well-to-do. "At the end of the day," says Beam, "the hospital's
goal is to succor patients, or right them, or just make them feel
confident enough to give the real world, with all its ferocity and
vicissitudes, one more try."
-- Reviewed by Bruce Fellman

Harriet
Scott Chessman '79PhD
Lydia
Cassatt Reading the Morning Paper
Seven
Stories Press, $24.00
It
is Paris in September 1878 and Impressionist painter Mary Cassatt
is starting a new series of portraits. Cassatt's model is her terminally
ill sister Lydia, and in Chessman's graceful novel, the process
of making art serves as a vehicle for exploring the relationship
between the two women.
Each
of the five chapters revolves around breathing fictional life into
the creation of one of Cassatt's early masterpieces. It is a technique
that has been used often recently, most notably in Girl with
a Pearl Earring, Tracy Chevalier's best-selling evocation of
the Vermeer painting.
In
Chessman's book, however, the author appropriately employs deft
Impressionistic brushwork in "painting" the two sisters and Lydia's
narrowing world. As was evident in her first novel, Ohio Angels ("In Print," Summer 1999) Chessman has an eye and ear for the subtle
details of day-to-day life. Describing the "rushing sound" of Mary's
skirt as she moves, Lydia observes that "I cherish the way the room
fills with quiet, like a bowl filling with milk." There are poignant
accounts of love and lovers: Lydia's fiance, killed in the Civil
War, is a haunting presence, as she looks back over a life in which
circumstances and illness have made it impossible for her to have
her "most ardent wish" -- "to know another's touch, and to have
children of my own.."
Yet
there is no bitterness in this luminous novel. "I wish to throw
my arms around the day," says Lydia, "embrace it fiercely, make
it impossible for it to let me go."
-- Reviewed by Bruce Fellman

Carl
Zimmer '87
Evolution: The Triumph of An Idea
HarperCollins, $40.00
In
December 1831, a 22-year-old medical school dropout named Charles
Darwin boarded the H.M.S Beagle, a 90-foot-sloop docked in
Plymouth, England, to begin a five-year journey. The official purpose
of the voyage was to test clocks and navigation techniques for the
British navy, but Darwin had a slightly less lofty reason for being
onboard. The unemployed son of a physician-turned-financier was
on the Beagle simply to keep the captain company; unofficially,
Darwin was to serve as ship's naturalist. By all accounts, he became
rather good at this last task.
In
the companion volume to a PBS series that aired last fall, science
writer Zimmer takes readers with Darwin on his round-the-world trip
and then explores how the concept of evolution took shape in the
naturalist's mind and how it has itself evolved to become the main
organizing principle of biology. From a consideration of the evolution
of sex to a study of the coevolution of insects and flowers, the
author has put together a provocative look at what philosopher Daniel
Dennett called "Darwin's dangerous idea. the single best idea
that anyone has ever had."
Twenty
three years after the Beagle returned to England, Darwin
made his case for evolution in one of the most influential books ever written. The seeds for The Origin of Species were planted
during the naturalist's collecting days when he looked at his specimens
and realized that, contrary to the prevailing religious doctrines
of the 19th century, plants and animals had in fact changed over
time. Some had even become extinct. God was apparently not micromanaging
creation.
The
notion that life, including human life, could evolve on its own
by a process Darwin dubbed "natural selection" was profoundly disturbing
to many in that era. As Zimmer shows, that uneasiness continues,
with evolution often winding up in court -- the most famous case
is the Scopes monkey trial of 1922 -- or in politics, as occurred
in 1999 when the Kansas State Board of Education attempted to purge evolution from the science curriculum. (That initiative, which in
general was widely denounced, ended when its proponents on the Board
were voted out of office the following year.)
Zimmer
demonstrates that there continue to be debates over the details
of the evolutionary process, but he notes that for most scientists,
any battle over the central fact of evolution has long been over.
Darwin won. In The Origin of Species, "he promised his readers
'a grandeur in this view of life,'" says Zimmer, "and now life displays
far more grandeur than even Darwin appreciated."
-- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Elizabeth
Alexander '84, Associate Professor (Adjunct) of African
American Studies
Antebellum
Dream Book
Graywolf
Press, $14.00
In
her third book of poems, Alexander imagines the dream not as a foggy
substance that diffuses at dawn, but as a constant force pulsing
behind great change. The thread of the dream weaves through her
poems, which touch upon moments on both the national and personal
levels.
Of
the race riots in Philadelphia in the 1960s, she writes, "Did I
see this yesterday? Did I dream / this last night? The city is burning,
/ is burning for real." She also takes on the voice of a runaway
slave in "Nat Turner Dreams of Insurrection," where the dream provides
a wellspring for spiritual endurance, even when basic physical needs
are lacking: "Freedom: a dipperful of cold well water. / Freedom:
the wide white sky. / Dreams that make me sweat." Here, even though
the dream causes distress of the night sweats, it serves as inspiration
in a time of crisis to prod the dreamer toward the goal of survival
and peace.
-- Reviewed
by Jennifer L. Holley

Brief
Reviews
Edward
Bliss Jr. '35
Beyond the Stone Arches: An American Missionary Doctor in China,
1892-1932
W.W. Norton, $27.95
A journalist son tells the remarkable story of his father, a member
of the Class of 1887 and 1891MD, who abandoned a promising career
to answer a call to become a medical missionary -- "doctoring and
farming" in China for 40 years.
James
Meyer '84
Minimalism: Art and Polemics in the Sixties
Yale University Press, $50.00
After World War II, a group of avant-garde painters and sculptors
conceived an art form stripped down to the barest essentials. Meyer,
an art historian, examines minimalism and the controversies that
swirled around its practitioners.
William
Storandt, Tutor, Bass Writing Program
Outbound: Finding a Man, Sailing an Ocean
University of Wisconsin Press, $29.95
Crossing the Atlantic on board the aptly named sailboat Clarity, Storandt, who teaches writing at Yale, evokes life at sea as he
recounts a classic journey of self-discovery.
Jessica
Teich '81 and Brandel France de Bravo
Trees Make the Best Mobiles: Simple Ways to Raise Your Child in
a Complex World
St. Martin's Press, $22.95
Two busy mothers advise parents to "do less, listen more," and adopt
an approach called "present parenting" -- being "present in the
moment."The authors contend that "our presence, our focus, is our
greatest gift."
Jeff
Wheelwright '69
The Irritable Heart: The Medical Mystery of the Gulf War
W.W. Norton, $26.95
Ten years after the Gulf War, many veterans remain sick, suffering
from a suite of ill-defined symptoms. Wheelwright, a science writer,
investigates the controversial Gulf War syndrome and concludes that
it's real.
Dick
Wimmer '59MA
The Irish Wine Trilogy
Penguin, $13.00
Novelist Wimmer follows the madcap adventures of a memorable lead
character, painter Seamus Boyne, along with his daughter Tory and
best friend Hagar, on both sides of the Atlantic in a trilogy that
combines wit, philosophy, sex, and great storytelling.

Books
Received
Alita Anderson 2001MD
On the Other Side: African Americans Tell of Healing
Westminster/John Knox Press, $19.95
Alexander Blackburn 1951
Creative Spirit
Creative Arts Books, $15.95
Jonah Blank 1986
Mullahs on the Mainframe: Islam and Modernity Among the Daudi
Bohras
University of Chicago Press, $40.00
Paul F. Boller Jr. 1939,
1947PhD
Presidential Inaugurations
Harcourt, $25.00
Wickham Boyle 1981MPPM
A Mother's Essays from Ground Zero
Phoenix Press, $20.00
L. Perry Curtis Jr. 1953
Jack the Ripper and the London Press
Yale University Press, $35.00
William V. D'Antonio 1948,
James D. Davidson, Dean R. Hoge, and Katherine Meyer
American Catholics: Gender, Generation, and Commitment
Altamira Press, $19.95
David Brion Davis, Sterling Professor of History
In the Image of God: Religion, Moral Values, and Our Heritage
of Slavery
Yale University Press, $35.00
Lawrence F. Gall 1984PhD,
Head of Systems, Peabody Museum, and Jacques Gauthier, Professor
of Geology and Geophysics, Editors
New Perspectives on the Origin and Early Evolution of Birds:
Proceedings of the International Symposium in Honor of John H. Ostrom
Yale Peabody Museum, $49.00
Gene M. Grossman 1977
Special Interest Politics
MIT Press, $40.00
James F. Hoge Jr. 1958 and
Gideon Rose 1985, Editors
How Did This Happen? Terrorism and the New War
PublicAffairs/ Perseus Books, $14.00
Maggie Jackson 1982
What's Happening to Home: Balancing Work, Life, and Refuge in
the Information Age
Sorin Books, $19.95
Lawrence Kramer 1972PhD
Musical Meaning: Toward a Critical History
University of California Press, $55.00
Robert Mendelsohn 1978PhD,
Edwin Weyerhaeuser Davis Professor, School of Forestry and Environmental
Studies, Editor
Global Warming and the American Economy: A Regional Assessment
of Climate Change Impacts
Edward Elgar Publishing, $80.00
Richard A. Posner 1959
Antitrust Law, Second Edition
University of Chicago Press, $35.00
Neil Rolde 1953
The Interrupted Forest: A History of Maine's Wildlands
Tilbury House, $20.00
Robert S. Rosefsky 1957
Personal Finance, Eighth Edition
John Wiley and Sons, $87.95
Ann Satterthwaite 1960MCP
Going Shopping: Consumer Choices and Community Consequences
Yale University Press, $39.95
Lucy Schaeffer 1999, Illustrator,
and Cal Fussman, Writer
The Guest Who Threw Tomatoes
Un-Identical Twins Press, 10.95
John W. Streeter 1931, Annotator
Nathanael Greene Herreshoff, William Picard Stephens: Their Last
Letters, 1930-1938
Herreshoff Marine Museum, $49.95
Jessica Teich 1981 and Brandel
France de Bravo
Trees Make the Best Mobiles: Simple Ways to Raise Your Child
in a Complex World
St. Martin's Press, $22.95
Calvin Trillin 1957
Tepper Isn't Going Out: A Novel
Random House, $22.95
Susan Weiner, Associate
Professor of French
Enfants Terribles: Youth and Femininity in the Mass Media in
France, 1945-1968
Johns Hopkins University Press, $38.00
Robert E. Willoughby 1948MDiv
Twenty-First Century Christianity: Dilemmas the Church Must Face
or Die
Fithian Press, $12.00 |