|
In Print
Summer
2001
Brief
Reviews
Books Received
David
McCullough '55
John
Adams
Simon
& Schuster, $35.00
The biographer
of John Adams, the second president of the United States, has an
easy task in some ways. The staunch New Englander was not just present
at the creation of the Republic -- as an original member of the
Continental Congress, as adviser on nation-building, and as a well-traveled
broker of loans, alliances, and finally independence -- but Adams
also left a paper trail of superhighway proportions: decades' worth
of diary entries and voluble letters that reveal the man. If the
biographer is David McCullough, author of Truman and veteran
PBS commentator, the reader can be assured that the personal element
is never peripheral and the history is always lived and felt.
But any
biography of Adams also faces some hurdles. Hardly the most colorful
of the Founders, the man was more scholar than politician, often
solitary, deliberate and exacting, and not above pomposity. If JFK
tried to be the Jefferson of his age, Adams is the kind of figure
a Nixon might identify with.
It was
Adams who first discovered the frustration of the vice presidency,
which he called "the most insignificant office that ever the invention
of man contrived or his imagination conceived. [all parties] know
that I can do them neither much good nor much harm." He wasted his
first months in office debating the proper title for the U.S. chief
executive (Adams's quixotic preference: "his majesty the president
of the United States") and was largely ignored by George Washington.
At a time of divisiveness between Federalists and Republicans, Adams
was the "dark horse" chosen to succeed Washington.
Even
his detractors acknowledged Adams's integrity and dedication, qualities
that emerge forcefully here. We are spared none of the weaknesses -- neither his awkwardness while serving as the first ambassador
to Great Britain, nor the failure to secure his political base,
which led to his loss of the presidency to Jefferson in 1800.
Yet McCullough's
sympathy resides clearly with his protagonist, while Madison, Hamilton,
and especially Jefferson (an inveterate shopper, always in debt)
prove petty and diabolical by turns. This study gives a fascinating
account of the early political and diplomatic history of the Republic,
before presidents were elected by universal suffrage and when the
vice presidency went to the runner-up, regardless of party. With
a novelist's flair, McCullough brings both period and places to
life.
The Adams-Jefferson
relationship provides a strong dramatic arc, from early friendship
to cold coexistence, and then from political enmity to a final reconciliation,
due mostly to Adams's magnanimity. The backbone of the story is
an account of the Adams marriage, a union based on deep bonds of
affection and respect between John and Abigail that was strengthened
by their long periods of separation.
This
is a biography of a figure too statesmanlike to have survived long
in Washington. "No man who ever held the office of President," Adams
stated in a moment of hard-earned insight, "would congratulate a
friend on obtaining it."
--Reviewed by David
J. Baker '78PhD

Jennifer
G. Ackerman '80
Chance in the House of Fate: A Natural History of Heredity
Houghton
Mifflin, $25.00
Rachel
Carson, the late naturalist and writer, once wished that each child
in the world could be granted "a sense of wonder so indestructible
that it would last throughout life." In her first book, Notes
from the Shore (Yale Alumni Magazine, May 1995), Ackerman
showed that she was the recipient of Carson's gift, and in this
work, she demonstrates that her "sense of wonder" is alive and well.
Chance
in the House of Fate is an elegant examination of how recent
discoveries in the science of heredity have shown that all life,
despite the obvious external differences, is fundamentally similar
at the level of genes and proteins. The author is a genial and patient
guide on this tour of the inner workings of bacteria and nematode
worms, fruit flies and humans, and Ackerman's excitement over the
"little wows" is never far from the surface. "And listen to this,"
she tells readers, "rats engaged in the act of mothering sprout
abundant new brain cells and do better than virgin females in tests
of learning and memory."
The book
is full of surprises and insights, and like such masters as Annie
Dillard and Barry Lopez, Ackerman connects science and the humanities.
For example, in discussing the limits of genetic inventiveness,
she writes that "we are sheathed in the shapes of the past . preventing
the possibility of moving in certain directions and closing behind
us the gate of conceivable gifts. 'Nature is what you may do,' wrote
Emerson. 'There is much you may not.'"
Understanding
how these "conceivable gifts" could be both inherited and denied
took on special urgency for Ackerman, who weaves a family tragedy -- her sister had serious birth defects -- into her narrative. "When
I was pregnant with my first child, I was shocked by the idea that
it required no thought at all for me to sculpt a whole other person,"
says Ackerman. "But at night, I worried about what I held."
Probably
every mother has had the same fear, but, as Ackerman would learn,
"The miracle is this: From the looping cascades of communication
and control emerge the particular parts of a body in perfect form,
nearly every time." -- Reviewed
by Bruce Fellman

Jay
Winik '80, '93PhD
April 1865: The Month That Saved America
HarperCollins,
$32.50
History
is filled with "what if's," and nowhere is this more apparent than
in April 1865, the tumultuous month marked by the the surrender
of Robert E. Lee to Ulysses S. Grant, the assassination of Abraham
Lincoln, and the transition to power of Andrew Johnson. In an engaging
study, historian Jay Winik explores what he calls "one of America's
finest hours," the pivotal period during which the Civil War came
to an end and the rebuilding of the United States began.
It was
a month that saved the nation, the historian argues, but the events
of April 1865 could have just as easily unraveled the country."What
if [Lee] had decided that honor lay not in surrendering but in fighting
on and on for the mother South -- with organized guerrilla warfare?
Or if Grant and Sherman had neglected Lincoln's admonitions and
responded not with generosity of spirit, but with unbridled anger?
Or if after the assassination of Lincoln, all went to pieces?" asks
Winik.
The historian
brings to life events such as Lee's poignant request that his men
be allowed to take their horses and Grant's wise acquiesence, and
the harrowing night at Ford's Theatre on April 14 and its aftermath.
"Nowhere did the Constitution promise perpetuity for the United
States as a country," writes Winik, but in showing what happened
and why alternative paths weren't followed, he demonstrates its
enduring strengths. -- Reviewed by Bruce Fellman

Elisabeth
Gitter '72PhD
The Imprisoned Guest: Samuel Howe and Laura Bridgman, the Original
Deaf-Blind Girl
Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, $25.00
Half
a century before Helen Keller's struggle to overcome both deafness
and blindness captured national attention, a young girl named Laura
Bridgman conquered similar handicaps and won considerable acclaim.
"Rescued" from a New Hampshire farm and schooled at the Perkins
School for the Blind in Boston by educational reformer and abolitionist
Samuel Gridley Howe, Bridgman's accomplishments were so enthralling
that thousands of people came to see her on "exhibition days," and
Charles Dickens told her story in American Tales.
But despite
Bridgman's fame in the middle of the 19th century, her story was
all but lost. Reading Dickens, Elizabeth Gitter, a specialist in
Victorian studies, rediscovered the tale and located, in the Perkins
basement, "bundles and boxes of uncataloged, unpublished manuscripts."
From this trove, the historian assembled a compelling picture of
a feisty, though difficult, spirit; her dedicated and conflicted
teacher Howe; and an era during which attitudes towards the care
and status of the handicapped began to change. "Laura's story still
matters," says Gitter. "She was the first: the pioneering experiment
and the living proof that a deaf-blind child could learn verbal
language."
-- Reviewed by
Bruce Fellman

Connie
Voisine '86
Cathedral of the North
University of Pittsburgh Press, $12.95
Drawing
on her upbringing in northern Maine, Connie Voisine has crafted
rich poems in her first book, the winner of the 1999 Associated
Writing Programs' Award Series in Poetry. With simple yet ethereal
imagery, Voisine explores life in a town where a mother of a dead
child works "at a factory sewing zippers or punching snaps on thousands
of tiny pajamas (this is what women do here) and at our house the
yard blooms with refrigerators and cars insides out and rusting."
There
are references to the countryside as well. The slow-paced panorama
in "Booming the Lake" records the various effects of an explosion
on farm animals, and ends with the stunning image of people who
"watch for the white moon of a child's back to rise in the water,
cut loose by sound." For the inhabitants of the community, perched
in isolation at the top of the world, Voisine writes, "There is
what we desired, but mostly what we got instead."
In this
grim world, escapism thrives. In the Italo Calvino-inspired, "Invisible
City / Float," a village is remembered magically as an island that
floats in outer space, tethered to the ground. In this city, "The
only sound is one of crying./ .the way a ship cries, against
its ropes." Likewise, Voisine's poems, focused as they are on the
unvaulted sky, ache for ascension.
--Reviewed by Jennifer
L. Holley

Brief
Reviews
Peter
Brooks, Chester Tripp Professor of the Humanities
Troubling Confessions: Speaking Guilt in Law and Literature
University
of Chicago Press, $24.00
"The imperative to 'fess up is deeply engrained in our culture,"
writes Brooks, who examines fiction, film, and legal cases to explore
the act of admitting guilt.
Thad
Carhart '72
The Piano Shop on the Left Bank: Discovering a Forgotten Passion
in a Paris Atelier
Random
House, $23.95
A trip to an improbable cafe in the back of a piano repair shop
in Paris leads the expatriate author to rediscover a passion for
music and music-making that had been dormant since his childhood.
Allen
Forte, Battell Professor of the Theory of Music
Listening to Classic American Popular Songs
Yale
University Press, $35.00
From the 1920s through the 1940s, songsmiths like Cole Porter '13
and George Gershwin created a repertoire that has long captivated
listeners. The author discusses 23 classics, interpreted by Richard
Lalli and Gary Chapman on an accompanying CD.
Jonathan
Spence '65PhD, Sterling Professor
of History
Treason by the Book
Viking
Press, $24.95
An 18th-century Chinese emperor does the unexpected when he learns
of a letter that contains a plot against him. Historian Spence shows
that instead of ordering an execution, the emperor begins a correspondence.
Harold
H. Tittmann III '51, '54LLB
The Waldheim Affair: Democracy Subverted
Olin
Frederick, $22.95
In 1986, allegations surfaced that Kurt Waldheim, then a candidate
for president of Austria, was a Nazi war criminal. The author, a
corporate lawyer, makes a case that Waldheim was innocent.

Books
Received
Kent
Bloomer 1959BFA, 1961MFA Professor of Architecture (Adjunct)
The Nature of Ornament: Rhythm and Metamorphosis in Architecture
W.W.
Norton, $45.00
Jane
Dailey 1987
Before Jim Crow: The Politics of Race in Postemancipation Virginia
University
of North Carolina Press, $39.95
Michael
W.R. Davis 1953
Chrysler Heritage: A Photographic History
Arcadia
Publishing, $18.99
Trudy
G. Ettelson 1974PhD
Adventures in Writing: From Glitches to Glories. A Creative
Self-Help Book That Makes Writing Fun
Soul
Story Publications, $18.95
Alexander
Garvin 1962, 1967MArch, Professor of Architecture (Adjunct)
Parks, Recreation, and Open Space: A 21st-Century Agenda
American
Planning Association, $34.00
Pamela
Grundy 1984
Learning to Win: Sports, Education, and Social Change in 20th
Century North Carolina
University
of North Carolina Press, $39.95
Thomas
R. Holtz Jr. 1992PhD and Michael Brett-Surman
Jurassic Park Institute(TM) Dinosaur Field Guide
Random
House, $12.99
R.M.
Koster 1955
Glass Mountain: A Novel
W.W.
Norton, $24.95
Bruce
H. Mann 1977PhD and Christopher L. Tomlins, Editors
The Many Legalities of Early America
University
of North Carolina Press, $59.95
Armine
Kotin Mortimer 1974PhD
Writing Realism: Representations in French Fiction
Johns
Hopkins University Press, $42.50
Sally
M. Promey 1978MDiv and David Morgan, Editors
The Visual Culture of American Religions
University
of California Press, $60.00
Alexandra
Robbins 1998 and Abby Wilner
Quarterlife Crisis: The Unique Challenges of Life in Your Twenties
J.P.
Tarchner, $14.95
Adam
Rome 1980
The Bulldozer in the Countryside: Suburban Sprawl and the Rise
of American Environmentalism
Cambridge
University Press, $54.95
Steven
T. Rosenthal 1968, 1975PhD
Irreconcilable Differences? The Waning of the American Jewish
Love Affair with Israel
Brandeis/University
Press of New England, $24.95
Mark
B. Ryan 1974PhD
A Collegiate Way of Living: Residential Colleges and A Yale Education
Jonathan Edwards/Yale, privately published
David
Shanefield 1952
Industrial Electronics for Engineers, Chemists, and Technicians:
With Optional Lab Experiments
William
Andrew Publishing, $65.00
Hampton
Sides 1984, Editor
Why Moths Hate Thomas Edison: And Other Urgent Inquiries into
the Odd Nature of Nature
W.W.
Norton, $13.95
T.N.
Srinivasan, Samuel C. Park Jr. Professor of Economics, and N.S.S.
Narayana, Editor
Economic Policy and State Intervention: Selected Papers of T.N.
Srinivasan
Oxford
University Press, $45.00
Gay
Walker, Curator (retired), Arts of the Book Collection
Bonawit, Stained Glass, and Yale
Wildwood Press, $24.95
Meredith
Baldwin Weddle 1993PhD
Walking in the Way of Peace: Quaker Pacifism in the Seventeenth
Century
Oxford
University Press, $49.95
|