Comment on this article
Geronimo's descendants sue Skull and Bones -- and the U.S. Army
February 19, 2009
by Carole Bass '83, '97MSL
Three years after the Yale Alumni Magazine revealed new evidence that Skull and Bones may have robbed Geronimo's grave, his great-grandson is
suing for return of the relics. But Skull and Bones is only one of the defendants.
A lawyer for Harlyn Geronimo says he doesn't know whether any of the Apache
warrior's remains are in New Haven, and that Yale and its most notorious secret
society are not the main focus of the suit.
Of the "twenty-nine-page complaint, [PDF] Skull and Bones is only one paragraph," says the lawyer, Ramsey Clark, in a
telephone interview. "The main entity is the U.S. Army," owner of Fort Sill,
Oklahoma, where Geronimo was held as a prisoner of war and buried after his
death in 1909.
| |
The complaint also names President Barack Obama.
|
In 2006, the Yale Alumni Magazine printed a newly unearthed 1918 letter [PDF]
from one Skull and Bones member to another. It stated: "The skull of the worthy
Geronimo the Terrible, exhumed from its tomb at Fort Sill . . . is now safe
inside the T-- together with his well worn femurs[,] bit & saddle horn."
The abbreviation "T--" refers to the society's "Tomb," its mausoleum-like
clubhouse. (The letter was discovered by writer Marc Wortman during research
for his book about World War I Yale aviators, The Millionaires' Unit.)
Some experts believe that Skull and Bones desecrated the
wrong grave by mistake, and the skull they thought was Geronimo's
probably belonged to a different Native American. But there seems little
question that most of the Indian leader's remains are still buried at Fort
Sill. Perhaps surprisingly, Harlyn Geronimo's aim is not to return any missing
relics to Oklahoma, but rather to move all of his great-grandfather's remains to his New Mexico homeland.
In its own words, the federal suit seeks "to free Geronimo,
his remains, funerary objects and spirit from one hundred years of imprisonment
at Ft. Sill, Oklahoma, the Yale University campus at New Haven, Connecticut,
and wherever else they may be found," and to return them "to his native land,
at the headwaters of the Gila River among the surrounding mountains."
Clark contends that the Native American Graves Protection
and Repatriation Act gives Harlyn Geronimo and nineteen other blood relatives
"the right to ownership, control, and possession" of Geronimo's remains.
The first named defendant is President Barack Obama,
followed by the secretaries of defense and the army. Yale and the Order of
Skull and Bones finish out the list.
No one has emerged from the Tomb to comment on the lawsuit.
A university spokeswoman pointed out that Skull and Bones is legally independent of Yale.
Asked how confident he is that Skull and Bones actually has
Geronimo's skull or other relics, Clark replies simply: "We don't know. There's
been enough commentary about it over enough time that you can't ignore it. If
we're serious about getting control of all the remains, we had to sue them.
It's nothing personal." 
|